Showing posts with label Bharti. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bharti. Show all posts

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Stock Chart Pattern - Bharti Airtel (An Update)

In the previous update of the stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel posted on May 25 ‘11 (marked by grey vertical line on the chart below), negative divergences in the technical indicators – which failed to touch new highs with the stock’s price (marked by blue arrows) – led to the following concluding comments:

“The stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel is back in bull territory, but not yet out of the woods. Without a doubt, this is the best stock among the telecom service providers. But its glory days are behind it. As an investor, you always have choices. If you are going to invest in a slow growth, stalwart stock – would ITC or Dabur be better bets?”

If you are a die-hard fan of Bharti Airtel’s stock, you probably ignored my suggestion of a switch to ITC or Dabur. You may be suffering the consequences if you failed to sell when the stock hit its peak exactly a year ago. Incidentally, both ITC and Dabur would have been good candidates for a switch. While Bharti has lost 19% till date from its closing price of 369 on May 25 ‘11, ITC’s stock has gained 38% and Dabur’s stock gained a more modest 12%.

To grow one’s wealth, some times tough choices need to be made – specially when it involves getting rid of a hitherto outstanding performer in your portfolio. Many small investors must have faced a similar choice with the Infosys stock.

Bharti_Aug0212 

Despite the negative divergences marked in the daily bar chart pattern of Bharti Airtel, the stock kept rising for the next two months after my previous post and touched a two year high of 444.70 on Aug 1 ‘11. But it turned out to be a high volume ‘distribution day’ (open near day’s high and close near day’s low) that marked the end of a 14 months long bull rally. A small ‘rising wedge’ bearish pattern was formed as the stock touched its peak.

The subsequent bear phase in the stock’s price has completed a year. By touching an intra-day low of 280.10 on May 23 ‘12, the stock retraced 86% of its previous rally from the low of 254 (touched on Jun 2 ‘10). The ‘death cross’ of the 50 day EMA below the 200 day EMA in Dec ‘11 (marked by light blue oval) technically confirmed a bear market. The stock is trading below its falling 200 day EMA and the blue down trend line.

Technical indicators are bearish. MACD is falling below its signal line in negative territory. ROC is negative and below its 10 day MA, but trying to rise. RSI is moving sideways below its 50% level. Slow stochastic has entered its oversold zone.

Bottomline? The stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel is falling deep into a bear market – touching lower tops and lower bottoms. The stock hasn’t found a bottom yet. There is no point in trying to catch a falling knife. If it falls below 280, it can test its Jun ‘10 low of 254. Avoid, till the stock price makes a reversal pattern. The company is under scrutiny by regulatory authorities for huge tax evasion.

Saturday, December 10, 2011

Can telecom sector stocks be contrarian bets?

Not much has changed in my bearish views about the telecom sector stocks since I wrote the previous post a little over a year back. The Sensex and Nifty are in bear markets – so are most of the telecom stocks. But there are always a couple of stocks in every sector that flow against the tide. The telecom sector is no exception. But the answer to the question is: No.

The 2G scam has not yet reached a denouement, except that the former telecom minister and his cohorts are still enjoying free lunches, but behind bars. Those who bid too high in the 3G auctions tried to cut their losses by circumventing auction conditions by sharing resources. The headwinds in the sector remain strong.

Horizontal dotted lines on the two year bar charts below represent price levels at the time I wrote a bearish post back in Oct ‘09.

MTNL

MTNL_Dec0911

The MTNL stock chart shows why the government should concentrate on making policies that enable businesses to prosper, but not be in business. A monopoly in the lucrative Delhi and Bombay markets couldn’t help the company to gain any competitive advantage. The stock is falling further in a bear market. Avoid.  

Bharti Airtel

Bharti_Dec0911

Bharti Airtel is the leader in the telecom pack. After dropping to a low of 254 in Jun ‘10, the stock had been in an up trend that reached a peak of 445 in Aug ‘11. The bears decided enough was enough. The stock has fallen below its 200 day EMA, the blue up-trend line and is just about hanging on to the two years old price level of 359. A drop to 325 is possible. Hold.

Reliance Communications

RelCommi_Dec0911

The Reliance Communications stock has lost 75% from the two years old level of 282 to its recent low of 69 – and may drop lower. The only hope for shareholders (those poor souls who are still hanging on) is if ‘big brother’ bails out ‘little brother’. Do not touch with a 10 ft pole.

Idea Cellular

Idea_Dec0911

In my previous post, Idea Cellular was recommended as a contrarian play, and is the only stock to make some gains in the past two years. Though technically in a bull market, the good times seem over for now. Book profits, or hold with a strict stop-loss at 80.

Tata Teleservices (Mah.)

TataTele_Dec0911

Tata TeleServices is at a critical support level of 14. All efforts at rallies have been met with selling by bears. If 14 is broken – and the probability is high, it may become a penny stock. Avoid.

Subex

Subex_Dec0911

The stock of Subex had made a good recovery and was forming the handle of a possible cup-and-handle bullish pattern. Only, the handle turned into the first leg of a down trend that has pushed the stock price deep into a bear market. The stock has lost 70% from its Nov ‘10 high of 95 to the recent low of 28. THe market has punished companies with high debt. Avoid.

OnMobile Global

OnMobile_Dec0911

The OnMobile stock has been pummeled out of shape – an example of how sentiments can play havoc with a fundamentally strong stock. For the past few months, the stock has been consolidating within a rectangular band between 54 and 73. There is a good possibility of the stock trying to form a bottom here. This can be a contrarian bet, but with a strict stop-loss at 52.

Geodesic

Geodesic_Dec0911

The Geodesic stock was a favourite of small investors in the previous bull market – thanks to the presence of the ‘RARE’ bull. But I could never figure out how they were making money (in spite of working in the IT industry for almost 30 years). The company has spun a web of subsidiary companies – many of which are located in tax havens. “Daal may zuroor kuchh kaala hai”! THe stock is falling deeper into a bear market. Stay far away.

Tanla Solutions

Tanla_Dec0911

Tanla was falling deep inside a bear market when I looked at it a year back. The chart is an example of how a stock which has already fallen a lot can fall much further. It has become a penny stock. Avoid.

MRO-Tek

MROTek_Dec0911

MRO Tek has also turned into a penny stock in spite of being around for more than two decades and being in the growing telecom and networking hardware business. Those who trade in this stock are either very brave or very foolish. Volumes indicate that their numbers are quite small. Don’t touch it.

Related Post

Should Indian investors switch out of Telecom Sector stocks?

Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Stock Chart Pattern - Bharti Airtel (An Update)

The previous update of the stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel was written way back in Jan ‘10. Prior to that, I had written a post in Oct ‘09 advising investors to switch out of telecom sector stocks. Despite growth in subscribers, low ARPUs, competition from overseas players with money power, and the likely high cost of the impending 3G auction were the reasons for my bearish view at that time.

Bharti’s stock had been an outstanding performer, giving multibagger returns to savvy investors who had entered early. Customer service was the best among the various service providers. The management was aggressive and clued on. But all sectors eventually mature. The fast growth of the early years tend to slow down to more stable and sustainable levels. Bharti was no exception.

The charts began to reflect the ground realities. The stock reached a high of 495 (adjusted for the subsequent 2:1 split) on May 19 ‘09 – thanks to the post-election market euphoria – but failed to test its Oct ‘07 top of 575. After a sharp correction, followed by a sideways consolidation, the stock attempted another rally – only to reach a lower top of 467 on Oct 1 ‘09. Combined with the fundamental headwinds, the weakness in the chart pattern confirmed that worse was to follow.

The bar chart pattern of Bharti Airtel from Jan ‘10 onwards shows that the worst may be over for shareholders, but there are technical hurdles that need to be crossed:

Bharti_May2511

The stock continued to fall below its 200 day EMA after my previous post on Jan ‘10, till it fell below its Mar ‘09 bear market low of 272 and made three bottoms at 254 in quick succession (two in May ‘10 and one in Jun ‘10). An upward spike above the 50 day EMA on decent volumes was followed by a bullish rounding bottom pattern. A high volume spike took the stock above its 200 day EMA.

The subsequent rally reached a high of 376 on Sep 28 ‘10. Note that the ROC and RSI made lower tops (marked by blue arrows) while Bharti’s stock moved higher. The inevitable correction turned into a 6 months long sideways consolidation till Mar ‘11. The sharp rally in Apr ‘11 did not have volume support. The ROC and RSI were making lower tops (blue arrows). The negative divergences once again stalled the rally.

The high volume spike on May 6 ‘11 touched an intra-day high of 400.10 before closing lower than the previous day – a distribution day. The rise from the low of 254 to the high of 400.10 retraced 60.6% of the fall from 495 (May ‘09) to 254 - close to the Fibonacci retracement level of 61.8%. The stock needs to clear 400 convincingly (i.e. by at least 3%), and then cross the previous tops of 467 and 495 before the bulls can regain control.

The technical indicators are not conducive to bullishness. The MACD is positive, but falling below its signal line. The ROC is just above its 10 day MA, and barely positive. The slow stochastic is below its 50% level. Only the RSI is showing some bullishness by rising above its 50% level.

Shareholders who heeded my advice and sold the stock on Oct 7 ‘09 (it touched a high of 367.70 and closed at 358.35) would have made more money even if they kept the cash in a savings account. At today’s closing price of 369, the stock has gained less than 3%.

Bottomline? The stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel is back in bull territory, but not yet out of the woods. Without a doubt, this is the best stock among the telecom service providers. But its glory days are behind it. As an investor, you always have choices. If you are going to invest in a slow growth, stalwart stock – would ITC or Dabur be better bets?

(My friend, Nishit, didn’t agree with my bearish view about Bharti and wrote a well-argued opposing view: http://investmentsfordummieslikeme.blogspot.com/2010/07/bullish-case-for-bharti-airtel-guest.html. What are your views about Bharti, dear reader? Are you bullish or bearish? Why?)

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Should you invest in Telecom Sector stocks?

Regular readers of this blog may be aware of my bearish view about the telecom sector. I had written a post back in Oct ‘09, advising investors to switch out of telecom sector stocks. There were many reasons for such advice: commoditised services, strong competition from overseas players, regular capital expenditure, astronomical fees for new licences, falling ARPU (average revenues per user).

Adding to the litany of woes for the sector is the 2G licence scam that has cost the Telecom Minister his job. The government is under severe pressure from the opposition to act due to several recent scams involving massive sums of money. Any action may lead to fines and penalties on telecom service operators who either obtained their 2G licences through dubious means, or paid too little for it, or sold their licences to others at huge profits.

Does that mean all the stocks in the sector should be shunned? Given below are ten telecom sector stock charts – five of them are telecom service providers and the other five provide software services and network hardware. All the charts have a horizontal line representing the closing price of the stock on Oct 6 ‘09 (the day I wrote my bearish post on the telecom sector).

MTNL

MTNL

This PSU, which had a monopoly on fixed line services in Delhi and Mumbai, has fallen on hard times. It slipped into a loss last year and has dropped below the falling 200 day EMA. Both the RSI and slow stochastic are in oversold zones. Use any rises to sell.

Bharti Airtel

BhartiAirtel

Bharti Airtel is the jewel among the telecom pack, but has lost quite a bit of its lustre. Many investors are still bullish about the stock. However, barring a few days in Sep ‘10, the stock has remained below its Oct 6 ‘09 closing level of 359. The Zain acquisition in Africa is yet to add to the bottom line. The recent up move has ended with a head-and-shoulders bearish pattern with a neckline at 320. A pullback to the neckline may be an opportunity to sell.

Reliance Communications

RelComm

What can I say about the Reliance Communications stock chart? The Oct 6 ‘09 closing level of 269 seems a distant dream. Losses in three of the past four quarters. If you are holding this stock, ask yourself: Why?

Idea Cellular

IdeaCellular

What have we here? A telecom services company that is trading higher than its Oct 6 ‘09 price! Hand it to the management acumen of the Birlas and the innovative ad-campaign featuring the ‘baby B’  for turning the fortunes around at Idea Cellular. Steadily gaining market share, this stock is a good contrarian play – provided you wish to invest in the telecom sector.

Tata Teleservices (Mah.)

TataTele

Despite the Tata name and their best efforts, the bottom line is a sea of red. The stock has remained an underperformer. Sporadic moves above the falling 200 day EMA have been used as selling opportunities. Avoid.

Subex

Subex

The Subex stock – a favourite of investors in the previous bull market – got hammered during the economic downturn and slipped into the red. The telecom fraud management software provider has since turned around, and is forming a bullish cup-and-handle continuation pattern. The break out above the Oct 6 ‘09 closing price has been on strong volumes. The dip (forming the ‘handle’) can be used to add. The huge debt burden makes this a high-risk play.

OnMobile Global

OnMobile

Despite its strong pedigree, the OnMobile stock has remained expensive and an underperformer. The value-added software niche has promise that hasn’t yet been turned into performance. One of its big clients – Vodafone – is facing a huge income tax liability. Even now, it is trading at an expensive TTM P/E of 25. Only very patient long-term investors should think about entering this stock.

Geodesic

Geodesic

The Geodesic stock spent the better part of the past 13 months below the Oct 6 ‘09 closing price. Of late, it has moved up sharply to regain most of its lost ground. The stock appears fundamentally sound, but I have neither been able to figure out its business model nor the reason for its considerable unsecured loans. As the old saying in the market goes: if in doubt, stay out.

Tanla Solutions

Tanla

I really have no idea what they do, or who they do it to. Four straight quarters of losses and a chart that looks like a roller blader going down an icy road is enough to convince me not to give a second look to Tanla Solutions.

MRO-Tek

MROTek

This network hardware provider has been around for long, but achieved little. I hate to admit it, but I did own this stock for several months during the previous bull market and was fortunate to exit with a tidy profit. Only good for medium-term trading. Not an investment candidate.

Related Post

Should Indian investors switch out of Telecom Sector stocks?

Thursday, July 15, 2010

The bullish case for Bharti Airtel - a guest post

Readers of this blog may know that I am not very hopeful about a rosy future for the telecom services industry in India, and aired my bearish views in a post back in Oct '09.

My friend Nishit was one of the first to write back with his counter arguments. I continue to remain sceptical about telecom services sector stocks, while Nishit is much more optimistic. He has written a guest post with his well-argued bullish views.

Please be generous with your comments, so that Nishit may get motivated to present his views every month - and readers will get the benefit of a different outlook and experience. Without further ado, here is Nishit's post.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What does one look for while buying a stock? Let me begin this post by asking the question which most of us grapple with every time we think of buying a stock.

A company with ethical Management, a business model which is scalable, a sector which offers immense growth potential, and right valuations. If our stock has all these four attributes then we have a winner on our hands.

Let us start by talking about the Sector. The Indian Telecom story is a strong and vibrant example of our progress in the world. This is due to the enabling policies of the government in liberalizing the sector and an example of private sector entrepreneurship.

We have 654 million mobile phone subscribers (as of May 2010) - second largest after China, and one of the fastest growing markets in the World. It’s not the numbers that excite me, or the number of subscribers being added. It’s the potential for exploiting the 3G and Wireless Broadband services.

Mobile Number Portability (MNP) has been further delayed to October 2010. Implementation of this will only benefit the big players. This is because the heavy spenders want good quality networks that the big players offer. The people who will switch from Bharti or Vodafone will be the low-end folks who will want to save the extra penny.

India is a country where Broadband penetration has been poor. This is due to the lack of infrastructure and laying out of cables across the country. Wireless Broadband wipes out the problem in one sweep. The existing cell phone towers can be used to relay the transmission.

Data Services would be the key going forward. Today, Corporates use the Photo Data card for access of its employees to their networks after office hours. The minimum amount of rent paid is Rs 500 and upward. This is just a precursor of things to come with 3G rollout. As we move forward towards 4G and 5G, broadband capacities would permit us to watch Television on mobile phones using the bandwidth.

Rural India suffers from acute shortage of infrastructure. Using Wireless, the government can leapfrog this bottleneck and offer various services like Mobile Banking, Weather Updates, and Health-care, using Tele-medicine. The key as usual lies in the execution.

Bharti is India’s largest pan-India operator with almost 30% market share in terms of revenue. It is better to look at the revenue than the number of subscribers. More importantly, Bharti has a large number of corporate subscribers who use the entire gamut of services offered by Bharti in terms of mobile connections, and bandwidth for Internet connectivity. Bharti also has landing stations for Internet gateways from abroad.

Another business stream, which is currently loss making for Bharti, is DTH, or Direct to Home Services. This I believe is the future for satellite TV viewing in India. The cable operators do not offer High Definition (HD) broadcasts, there is no transparency and no control over what one can watch. Many times I end up missing Formula One racing because the cable guy has only 3 channels available for sports and is showing Cricket on two of them and Football on the third. No cable operator offers recording of live television or pay-per-watch movies.

Bharti has 2.5 Million subscribers now and about 25% market share in incremental subscriptions. The Indian Telecom story would get saturated in new subscriber acquisitions sooner or later. Bharti has taken over the Zain operations in 15 countries in the African continent. This would catapult Bharti to Number 5 in the World in terms of subscribers.

Bharti has a very strong Management led by Sunil Bharti Mittal. It also has a very good second line that takes care of operations (like Manoj Kohli and Akhil Gupta). The investors in Bharti Airtel include Singtel, which owns about 32% of Bharti.

The Downside Risk comes from further price wars in this sector. We believe that eventually there would be a shakeout with only 3-4 operators other than BSNL and MTNL existing per circle.

Bharti is currently trading just under Rs 300, with EPS of Rs 24.39 and P/E of about 12. One could add on declines closer to its 52 week low of Rs 255 and hold it for 5 years.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Nishit Vadhavkar is a Quality Manager working at an IT MNC. Deciphering economics, equity markets and piercing the jargon to make it understandable to all is his passion. "We work hard for our money, our money should work even harder for us" is his motto. Nishit blogs at Money Manthan.)

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Do you invest with your head, or do you invest with your heart?

One of the building blocks - may be the most important one - of becoming a successful investor is to know yourself. To help you understand if you invest with your head or your heart, here are some practical situations that you are likely to face:-

1. March is usually the time for last-minute tax-saving investments. So you start looking at some ELSS funds. You hold the SBI Magnum Tax Gain fund since Mar '07. It was one of the best ELSS funds then and gave good dividends.

Your head tells you to sell it because of its recent under-performance and switch to Canara Robeco Tax Saver or DSPBR Tax Saver. Your heart urges you to stick with it as it will surely return to its earlier glory.

2. The Nifty is trading just short of its Jan '10 high for the past 6 trading sessions. Your head is saying 'be careful' because a previous top made some time ago can be a tough hurdle to cross. Your heart is saying 'a new high is imminent' and this is the time to jump in.

3. You had made a killing in the Bharti Airtel stock when you sold part of your holdings when it hit 1200 (pre-split) back in 2007. The rest of your holding effectively became 'free of cost'. Ever since, the stock has been sliding, but you held on because your holding cost was zero.

Your head is urging you to get rid of it, as the entire telecom services space has lost its pricing power with the entry of big global players. Your heart is forcing you to hold on because Bharti has proven management and the stock will definitely move above 500 soon.

4. Your decision to pick up OnMobile Global shares at 250 in Mar '09 turned out to be a really judicious move, as the stock zoomed to hit 700. Out of the blue, the bears attacked and the stock halved in value to 350.

Your head is accepting the fact that you got a lucky break initially, but you goofed by not booking profits at 700. Your heart is considering it as plain bad luck that your smart pick suddenly changed direction through no fault of yours.

5. You read my blog post about Indraprastha Gas back in July '09 when the stock was trading at 137. I had mentioned a possible target of 180. You decided to spend some time to research the stock thoroughly. But within a month, before you could gather sufficient details, the stock hit 180.

Your head told you to wait for better valuations. Your heart decided that you should buy before the stock runs away even higher.

6. Cranes Software was a hot stock in the previous bull market. It sold engineering software products to overseas clients and made huge profits. Because of the down turn, the stock hit the skids but at 45 it seemed like a screaming buy.

Your head warned you not to try and catch a falling knife. Your heart ignored the warning as the downside seemed very limited, and you bought a large chunk and then averaged down at 30.

If you are like most investors, you some times invest with your head and at other times invest with your heart. There are no guarantees which will be a better investor - your head or your heart. Logically, for long-term investors, the head should rule the heart. But stock markets can be illogical in the short-term.

Thursday, March 18, 2010

How to overcome Uncertainty in Stock Market investing

Many investors shy away from investing in the stock market because of the uncertainty of making any profits. A fixed deposit in a bank or an investment in a PSU bond has much less uncertainty. You are pretty much assured of getting back your invested capital, as well as earning some interest income.

In the stock market, there is uncertainty about receiving any income because a company is not obliged to pay any dividends even if it is making super profits. For example, a profitable company like Bharti Airtel paid its first dividend only in 2009 - 7 years after going public.

And there is uncertainty about getting back your invested capital. If you had bought Bharti at 600 in Dec '06, and sold at today's closing price of 300 (2:1 split adjusted) you would have actually lost a small part of your capital due to brokerage and tax payments.

But these are uncertainties that can be managed and, to a certain extent, measured. What we term as 'risk' is nothing but the possibility of having an unfavourable outcome. We can try to reduce the risk by quantifying the uncertainty of the outcome. How?

Let us say, you plan to buy 100 Tata Steel shares @600. You assign a probability of 80% that the stock will test its recent high of about 650.  There is also a 20% probability that the stock may drop to its 200 day EMA at 520. That means a 80% chance that you will make 5000 but a 20% chance that you will lose 8000. Your risk of loss can be quantified as: (600-520)x100x0.20= 1600.

After looking at the numbers, will you still decide to buy Tata Steel at 600? There is no reason why you shouldn't - specially if you have learned to set a stop-loss for all purchases. (Don't know how to set a stop-loss yet? You have only yourself to blame - because it is clearly laid out in Chapter 2 of my FREE eBook.)

What stock markets dislike are uncertainties associated with external factors and events, such as rate of inflation, interest rates, quarterly earnings results, oil prices, war, terror attacks, political climate. Adverse effects of such uncertainties usually get reflected immediately with 2 or 3 days of correction. Smart investors use such dips to buy.

But the worst uncertainty is about the state of the economy. If there is a possibility of a recession or a depression, stock markets tend to tank as investors rush to the exit doors and invest their money in safer havens.

The best way to overcome the fear associated with uncertainty is to always stay well-informed about the business and economic environment around you. Most business magazines and newspapers have web editions that you can browse without leaving your seat. Also visit web sites like CNN Money, FT and WSJ Marketwatch to get an international perspective. Make it a daily habit.

Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Stock Chart Pattern - Bharti Airtel (An Update)

My previous look at the stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel was back in Apr 29, '09 when the 2:1 stock split was announced. The stock had bounced off from an intra-day low of 272 (split-adjusted) on Mar 12 '09 and had sailed above the 200 day EMA.

The rise seemed too steep, and was devoid of volume support - which is essential for a bull rally to sustain. The post-election result euphoria took the Bharti Airtel stock to a high of 495 (split-adjusted) on May 19, '09 - but well short of its Oct '07 high of 575.

Let us take a look at the 1 year closing chart pattern of Bharti Airtel and see what transpired since then:-

Bharti_Jan1210

The bears attacked almost immediately as the stock dropped on much higher volumes. A sideways consolidation followed for the next 4 months. After making an intra-day low of 360 on Aug 11 '09 that took it below the 200 day EMA, the stock rose steadily to make a high of 467 on Oct 1 '09. The consolidation was marked by low volumes, which isn't unexpected. But the higher volumes on down days was a big negative.

Then the bottom fell out as the stock tanked on very high volumes. It finally dawned on investors that the heady growth of yesteryears had come to an end. Severe price competition from newer and bigger players had started to take a toll on the company's profit margins.

After making an intra-day low of 230 on Nov 27, '09 the stock made a valiant effort to move above the 200 day EMA. It managed to cross above the 50 day EMA and made an intra-day high of 349 on Dec 11 '09 - hitting exactly the 50% Fibonacci retracement level of the fall from 467 to 230.

Another period of sideways consolidation followed, that brought the 20 day EMA close to making a bullish cross above the 50 day EMA. Today's close of 319 has dropped the stock below the 50 day and 20 day EMAs. Technical indicators like the slow stochastic, RSI and MFI are showing negative divergences as they moved lower while the stock moved sideways.

What next? The impending 3G spectrum auction is going to cause a huge outflow of cash, at a time when continued price competition is clouding the future. The Bharti management, which has shown its mettle through thick and thin, may not be relishing the idea.

Which telecom service provider is going to make it through the next two years with its reputation and financial situation reasonably in tact? My guess will be Bharti. But that doesn't mean I'll bet my money on them. Fundamentally and technically, the stock is looking bearish.

Bottomline? The stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel is showing an interesting double bottom on a closing basis (279 on May 13 '09 and 281 on Nov 25 '09). A drop below 280 can take the stock to 220. Bulls have nothing to celebrate till the recent high of 349 is taken out. New entrants should avoid the stock. This is not the time to play contrarian.

Related Post

Should Indian investors switch out of Telecom Sector stocks?

Thursday, December 24, 2009

What is the Return on Assets (RoA) ratio?

The Return on Assets (RoA) ratio is a measure of profitability of a company relative to its total assets (which includes share capital plus all its short-term and long-term loans). It tells us how effectively and efficiently a company's management is utilising its assets to generate a profit.

There are a few different ways to calculate the RoA ratio (also called the Return on Investment ratio). The simplest is to divide the net profit during a 12 month period by the total assets. In other words,

Return on Assets (RoA) ratio = (Net profit / Total assets) x 100

If the Net profit of a company is Rs 5 Crores and total assets is Rs 100 Crores, then the RoA will be 5%. Another company may earn Rs 10 Crores on total assets of Rs 100 Crores. Its RoA will be 10%. Needless to say, the higher the RoA the better. Which means the company is able to generate more profits with less or equal amount of investment.

An RoA of 15% is considered the benchmark for profitability. But the figure is different for different industries. Therefore, the RoA should be used to separate the men from the boys within an industry or sector - and not used for comparing across sectors.

Why? Let us take a Bharti or RCom. They need to constantly invest in new equipment and towers for growth. Or, a Maruti or Tata Motors that need to innovate and invest in new models and infrastructure. Likewise, for power generating businesses like NTPC or Suzlon; airline companies like Jet and Kingfisher; metal producers. Such companies are asset-heavy. Therefore the RoA ratio tends to be 5% or lower.

Contrast these sectors with some asset-light ones like software services or travel services or brokerages. All you need are some furniture and computers and you are in business. Naturally, the RoA ratio is 20% or higher, because the real assets in these sectors are people.

The financial sector, particularly banks, need to constantly borrow money to loan it out again. So the RoA ratio can be as low as 1%. What is a small investor to do? Avoid banks and manufacturing, and only invest in services companies?

Obviously not. That would be putting all your eggs in one basket. Therefore, use the RoA ratio to find out which banks, or auto makers, or steel and power companies are more profitable than their peers in the same sector.

Some prefer to add the interest expenses to the net profit to calculate the RoA ratio. Others add the working capital requirements to the total assets. Which particular formula to use depends on the type of sector being analysed.

There is another formula to calculate RoA:

Return on Assets (RoA) ratio = (Net profit margin x Asset turnover ratio) x 100

where, Net profit margin = Net profit / Sales

and, Asset turnover ratio = Sales / Total assets

Mathematically, the second formula is the same as the first, but gives us a different view of a business. It shows that profitability can be attained in two different ways. The first is by increasing the net profit margin (by reducing costs, or better still, by charging premium prices - like the Tanishq retail stores of Titan). The second is by turning over your assets many times during the year (a practice followed by discount retail stores, like Pantaloon).

Related Post

How to distinguish between a good company and a great company
(Wishing all my blog readers from near and far a very merry Christmas and a happy 2010.)

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Some practical examples of Behavioural Finance

Some practical examples of Behavioural Finance will show a different aspect - more from the psychological point of view - at how and why investors buy and sell stocks. It goes against the grain of Efficient Market theory that is built upon rational decision making taking into account all available information.

One of the interesting advantages of writing a blog is that readers get an opportunity to react almost immediately and let the writer know what they think about his opinions. Thereby opening a direct window to the workings of their minds.

In a recent post, I had suggested that investors should bail out of the telecom sector stocks, instead of jumping in after the price correction. In another post, I suggested investors should sell the Punj Lloyd stock at every rise, after it posted awful Q2 '09 results.

The reactions were swift. While some agreed with my views, many did not. The arguments were strong and apparently 'rational'. But what about investment behaviour?

"Bharti Airtel is the best in customer service, has a pan-Indian network, is a leader with a stash of cash, will be less affected by the price war and number portability. So, the stock was a 'steal' at 350 and more should be bought if it slipped below."

Why 350? Because it was 30% lower than its recent high of 500? Possibly. The human mind likes to work with nice round numbers. A classic example of 'recency bias' in Behavioural Finance. The price of 500 had remained in the investor's mind as a 'recent high'.

A few more readers thought 350 was a good price to enter. An example of 'confirmation bias' - investors looking for confirmation of a 'buy' decision. What happened when the stock dropped to 340?

"I sold at 340 so that I can buy it back at 325", was one comment. An example of 'loss aversion'. This is one of the most insidious biases for long-term investment success. Instead of admitting a mistake and booking the small loss, an investor tries to take on additional risk to avert the loss.

I'm not sure what this particular investor did when the Bharti Airtel stock first fell to 325 and then went below 300.

A comment about Punj Lloyd was:

"I sold the stock at 290 and was happy to buy it back at 240. Will buy more if it goes further down. The company has a huge order book, has global operations and is a Larsen and Toubro in the making."

Now that the stock has dropped below 200, 'Regret theory' in Behavioural Finance suggests that the investor has probably avoided selling the stock and is holding on to it to avoid the regret of making a bad decision.

'Prospect theory' in Behavioural Finance postulates that investors behave differently in situations depending on whether they are faced with a loss or a gain. They feel more pain at the prospect of losses than they feel elated by an equivalent gain. In other words, a 10 point loss in a stock costing 100 may cause more distress, than a 10 point gain causes happiness.

In actual experiments with different groups of investors, when evaluating the prospect of a sure gain, most investors become risk-averse; but faced with sure loss, they become risk-takers.

No wonder, Benjamin Graham has written: "The investor's chief problem - and even his worst enemy - is likely to be himself."

Tuesday, October 27, 2009

How to use Financial News - revisited

With results season upon us, financial news is flooding the airwaves and the pink sheets. Some companies are declaring better than expected results - like Tata Motors and ITC. Others are disappointing the market with poor Q2 '09 shows - like Punj Lloyd and Tata Steel. A few had so-so results - like L&T.

I had written an earlier post on this subject when the market was down in the dumps. At that time, my suggestion was to categorise each item of financial news into 'great news', 'good news', 'bad news' and 'worse news'.

The stock market is in a much healthier state now, but is in the throes of a good correction. Does that put a spin on the decision making process? Not really. The same categorisation principle applies.

Let us take the examples of the companies mentioned above.

Tata Motors and ITC pleasantly surprised the market. The Jaguar-Land Rover deal was supposed to weigh down the former, and the bad monsoon was expected to affect the FMCG sector. The Tata group's huge resource raising capability helped to manage the large debt; plus the pick-up in commercial vehicle sales was 'good news'. So was ITC's considerable profits from cigarettes and reduced losses from FMCG.

What happens with such 'good news'? Stock prices usually perk up, which is used by smart investors to sell. Within a few days, the stocks tend to trade near their earlier range.

Punj Lloyd and Tata Steel declared results that were way below consensus estimates. Tata Steel's Corus debt hangover and poor offtake of steel in Europe wasn't entirely unexpected. But it is a fundamentally strong and well-managed company. The selling pressure on 'bad news' can provide re-entry points for smart investors.

Punj Lloyd's is a case of 'worse news'. Why? The management had given the impression that the Simon Carves UK penalty issue was not a big problem and will get resolved soon. Far from it. On top of their singular inability to generate cash from their core operations which led to their huge debt burden, the effort at hoodwinking investors have not gone down well at all.

The stock is falling off a cliff but still trading at a P/E of 19 at today's closing price of 202. Investors should not make the mistake of using this fall as a buying opportunity. Instead, sell at every rise. I won't be surprised if it revisits its March '09 low. A stock to avoid.

L&T's case is a little strange. While their results were not a major disappointment, the low rate of conversion from their huge order book is a concern for the market. This is not a buy on 'bad news' yet, because of the valuations. Patient investors should wait before re-entering.

The 'bad news' about Idea's results could be a harbinger of the overall derating of telecom stocks. Bharti's stock price got battered by 7% in anticipation of similar 'bad news'.

There has been no 'great news' among the financial news in the results season so far. The economy is still recovering, and unless the export-import business picks up to its earlier glory, the stock market may fail to reach greater heights.

Related post

Should Indian investors switch out of Telecom Sector stocks?

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Are you an irrational investor?

Otherwise perfectly logical and rational people tend to become irrational when they become investors. Why does it happen? An entire field of academic study has grown around this riddle - called Behavioral Finance.

One of the questions I often face goes like this: 'I bought XYZ Co. at 450 and was thrilled to see it go to almost 550 but didn't sell. Now its at 100. Should I buy more to bring down my average cost? When can I expect to get back my original price?'

A rational investor should have sold when the price rose 100 points in a short period, or when it came down from 550 to 450. At worst, he should have sold when the price dropped to 400.

Instead, he hung on till the price dropped to 25, but didn't buy then. Now that the price is up past 100 he wants to buy again. If I'm brutally honest, my answer to the two questions would be 'No' and 'Never'. He would be better off getting out now. Unfortunately, loss-aversion - another irrational trait - may keep him from doing just that.

That may be an extreme example, but it isn't that far fetched. Here is another one. Say you've bought a stock at 250, following which the stock drops to 175. You decide to hold on because you've done your homework and the fundamentals are strong.

Eventually, the stock starts rising again and reaches 225. What would you do? Sell and book a small loss? Or, hold on at least till you get back your cost price of 250? Chances are, you'll opt for the latter - only to see the stock hit 230 and start falling like a brick. You eventually book a loss at 200.

Let's look at another situation. You buy a stock at 50, and within a week it starts to soar, and soon reaches 80. You decide to ride the wave. Within 6 months, the stock hits 110. More than double your original investment! You are elated, and book profits.

The stock consolidates for a while, and then takes off again. You watch in horror as it scales 150, 200, 250, 300 within the next few months. The person who bought from you at 110 made more money, though you had entered at a much lower cost.

Holding on too long when a stock is falling, or getting out too soon when a stock is rising, or expecting to get back the cost price are common mistakes that tend to get repeated. But such irrational investor behavior can be corrected through awareness and experience.

A little more complicated behavior pattern but equally disastrous for your wealth is not knowing that you don't know something. An example of that happened after a recent post on the telecom sector. I had suggested that the best of the telecom sector may be behind us and investors should switch to other sectors.

I received several arguments about Bharti Airtel being a great company that looks after its customers, plenty of growth is still left in the sector, buying Bharti after the recent correction would be a smart move, and so on.

Did the telecom sector suddenly turn bad? No. But the signs of saturation were clearly visible. Introduction of even lower call rates and delay in 3G spectrum auction were the last straws. Poor subscriber additions for the leading players confirmed that the tide is turning.

Most investors, particularly those who had entered the sector early and made huge gains, may find it difficult to accept that a major shift is happening in the telecom sector. It is gradually becoming a slow-growth stalwart sector from being a fast-growth sunrise sector.

Accepting and learning from your mistakes and acknowledging that you may not know as much as you think you know are the steps towards becoming a rational investor rather than remaining an irrational investor.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

Should Indian investors switch out of Telecom Sector stocks?

Indian investors have several choices about investing in the Telecom Sector. But should they use the correction in the telecom sector stocks to jump in or bail out? Let us have a look at the players.

There is the behemoth of fixed line services - MTNL, whose stock has promised much and delivered little. BSNL is yet to be listed, but its performance leaves a lot to be desired. Both had misused their earlier monopoly by taking customers for granted and providing atrocious services.

Now they are trying to hang on to reducing market shares in a shrinking market. Both joined the wireless services bandwagon late. Efforts to provide new-age services like broadband (mostly ADSL) and IPTV have been marred by poor technology, slow implementation and lack of a service orientation.

Then there are the myriad wireless service providers, of whom Bharti Airtel has been the clear leader and Reliance Communications (RCom) the follower. This is one area where the Tatas have not done well at all. The other players are fighting to reach critical mass.

The 'hockey-stick' style growth in mobile telephony is showing signs of maturity. While subscriber growth continues to be good, ARPUs (Average Revenues per User) have been steadily falling. Strict government regulations on spectrum allocations, geographical operations, equipment purchase, and high licence fees leave very little room for flexibility in operations.

The service has become commoditised - with every one offering similar call plans and rates. The industry is very capital intensive with low sales to asset ratio. A Rupee needs to be spent for every Rupee earned. Ongoing maintenance and upgradation of technology is a constant drain on resources. Trying to generate new revenue sources through satellite TV services have further added to costs.

The last straw seems to be the entry of new overseas competitors like Virgin and DoCoMo. With per-second billing rates likely to become the industry standard, ARPUs will drop faster. This will benefit consumers but not the service providers. EPS will take an immediate hit, and the stocks are already being derated.

Lastly, there are the fringe players. Handset, network and switching equipment manufacturers are mostly MNCs, unlisted in India. The odd MRO-Tek has been around for years without the stock doing anything remarkable.

The value-added software providers space looks interesting, but has small players. Subex is making losses. OnMobile has good pedigree but the stock is expensive. Geodesic and Tanla seem to be doing well, but it is difficult to assess if their business models are sustainable and scalable.

So, the short answer to the question is: Yes. Why not invest in sectors where growth is visible and the future is less ambiguous?

(Many readers may not agree with my bearish views about the Telecom sector. I would like to hear your counter arguments.)

Tuesday, August 4, 2009

What is your Circle of Competence?

'You don't have to be an expert on every company, or even many. You only have to be able to evaluate companies within your circle of competence. The size of that circle is not very important; knowing its boundaries, however, is vital.' - Warren E. Buffett

If you are able to answer the question truthfully and without letting your ego come in the way, you will be well on your way to becoming a successful investor. Trouble is, even seasoned investors are some times unaware of how to answer the question.

So, here are some guidelines in helping you to find out.

Think about your family. Your parents, relatives, in-laws, cousins. What kinds of activities have they been associated with. A doctor in the family? She'll be able to help with pharmaceutical and medical devices companies. In the textiles business perhaps? He may help you understand all about synthetic and man-made fibres.

What about your education, training and work experience? A civil engineer? You will know about construction companies, cement companies, road projects. An electrical engineer? Power generation and distribution, electrical cables and meter companies, electrical appliances will be in your knowledge base.

Your upbringing, education, work experiences, financial stability will all influence your behaviour patterns, risk tolerance, ability to take independent decisions and awareness about what you can do, and what you can't.

That creates your Circle of Competence. Your knowledge base. It is entirely an individual's circle. Only you know what you know and how much you know. Never confuse familiarity with knowledge.

I may use a fancy Mach III Gillette razor every morning. But I have no idea how Gillette runs its business or if a hike in steel prices will dent its profits significantly or not.

You may be a Bharti Airtel customer for a number of years. You like their service and their all-India presence and fast growth. So you get excited by the announcement of a maiden dividend and stock split and pick up 200 shares. Then you hear about the MTN acquisition, which seems to be going nowhere. Is that good, or bad for Bharti shareholders? Should you sell, hold or buy more?

Before you buy a single share of a company, make sure you have a basic understanding of how that company operates. What do they sell? Who do they sell it to? Who are their competitors? Are they in a sector that is growing fast, or is it a cyclical business? If you don't have this knowledge, don't buy the share.

What if your Circle of Competence is very, very small? Say you have worked for 15 years in the software industry and really don't know much about anything else. You can still earn a fortune by buying and selling shares of Infosys, TCS, Wipro.

But that will be putting all your eggs in one basket. Better to have several baskets. How? By increasing your Circle of Competence. Meet people. Join investor groups. Learn about new businesses and industries. And read, read, then read some more. Books, magazines, web sites - information is all around you.

Be sensible in gathering information. Don't suddenly try to become an expert about the Shipping industry and the Baltic Dry index. First look at businesses for which you have developed software. Chances are, you have in-depth knowledge about their operations and processes already.

Just sticking to your Circle of Competence may be a good idea, because it takes out the guesswork from stock investments. But it is not enough. You still need to be able to identify good sectors and companies through fundamental analysis. Then use technical analysis to determine if this is a proper time to buy or sell.

Related posts

How to pick Stocks for Investment - Part III
What exactly is the Margin of Safety?

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Stock chart pattern discussions - hits and misses

In my individual stock chart pattern discussions on Wednesdays, 10 stocks have been covered so far. It may be worthwhile to do a reality check to find out what I had observed and inferred and how the chart patterns actually shaped up.

1.  ICI India - ICI had pierced and closed above its 200 day EMA before dropping below, and was consolidating between the 50 day and 200 day EMAs around the Rs 416 level. I had suggested: Good stock to accumulate in small quantities for conservative, long term investors.

ICI_May1109

The stock has slowly but steadily moved up well above its 200 day EMA and added about 15%. Nothing great, but can be counted as a 'hit'.

2.  Suzlon Energy - The stock was looking oversold. There was a possibility of a bounce up, but it could also go lower. My advice: Investors should not go anywhere near this stock. Adventurous traders may want to make a punt with very tight stop losses.

Suzlon_May1109

After going marginally lower, the stock moved up rapidly with the global rally and jumped up by almost 150%! It is still well below its 200 day EMA in spite of the sharp rise. A 'miss'.

3.  State Bank - SBI was looking like a value buy as it was trading at its book value. I observed the strong support at 900, but did not expect an up move to go beyond 1100.

SBI_May1209

SBI moved up 40% with the global rally before facing resistance at a previous top of 1400. Another 'miss'.

4.  Unitech - The stock was being accumulated near its 52 week bottom and I expected a move upwards. But advised: Unless the strong resistance between 50-60 levels is overcome, there is no point in entering Unitech.

Unitech_May1209

The stock did move up to the resistance zone of 50-60, but despite two attempts, was unable to cross it. A 'hit'.

5.  Hero Honda - This was one of the few stocks in a bull phase but at 1100 level was looking overbought and due for a correction. My suggestion: New investors may buy on dips. Existing investors should hang on tight and enjoy the ride.

HeroHonda_May1209

After correcting to Rs 1000, the stock has steadily moved up to Rs 1200 and continues in its bull phase with all three averages moving up.

6.  Reliance Capital - I had expected the stock to face some resistance at 490-500 before moving up to 625 level, and had advised short and long term investors to get in at the next dip.

RelCap_May1209

Reliance Capital sailed upwards to 580, reacted to 490 and then moved up to 625, where it faced resistance. I will count that as a 'hit', though the short term gain was only about 30%.

7.  Infosys - Despite a sell-off due to disappointing results that dropped the stock below its 200 day EMA, I had observed a 'rounding bottom' bullish pattern and advised: Wait for the selling pressure to subside before entering the stock on the dip. Be prepared for a longish wait for profits.

Infosys_May1209

The stock smoothly moved up from Rs 1300 to Rs 1600, well above its 200 day EMA. Another 'hit'.

8.  DLF -  A 'rounding bottom' bullish pattern was observed but the failure to cross the resistance level of Rs 300 led me to suggest: If you haven't got rid of your DLF holding yet, you may get one more chance to do so. There is a possibility that this rally is taking a pause before trying to move higher again.

DLF_May1209

The stock moved down to Rs 220 before moving up to Rs 269 to provide one more chance for investors to get out. A 'hit'.

9.  Bharti Airtel - The upward rally looked too steep. The lower volumes remain a concern. The 20 day EMA did move up above the 200 day EMA as expected. My advice: An existing holder can keep riding the rally or book partial profits.

Bharti_May1209

The stock has continued its upward move with a slight dip for 2 days. A 'hit'.

10. Balrampur Chini - The 50 day EMA did move above the 200 day EMA but instead of a correction, the stock is undergoing a triangular consolidation before the next up move. My suggestion: I would wait till the election results come out before entering.

Balrampur_May1209

It has been only five trading sessions since my discussion - too early to draw conclusions. A 'neutral'.

Without trying to be immodest, not a bad performance at all. Comments are welcome.

(Note: Please right-click on the charts and open them in a new tab or window for a better view.)

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Stock Chart Pattern - Bharti Airtel

The stock chart pattern of Bharti Airtel will reveal why it is one of the favourite stocks of institutional and retail investors. Not only has the company provided innovative products and services, its rapid growth has provided huge capital appreciation to investors.

Today it has announced a maiden dividend and a 2:1 stock split. That should further consolidate its leadership position as the stock-to-own in the telecom services sector.

The 6 months closing chart pattern of Bharti Airtel shows that it has been outperforming the Sensex during the recent rally:-

Bharti_Apr2809

(Please right-click on the image above and open it in a new tab or window for a better view.)

Bharti had six straight closes above its 200 day EMA, while the Sensex continued to play hide-and-seek with its long-term average. The rise from the Mar '09 low has also been much sharper than that of the Sensex.

The 20 day EMA has moved well above the 50 day EMA and is likely to pierce the 200 day EMA from below. That will be the first confirmation that Bharti Airtel has entered a bull phase.

The slow stochastics is comfortably ensconced in the overbought zone and not showing any signs of moving out. The MACD and its signal line are both rising.  The RSI is about to enter the overbought zone. All good signs for the up move to continue.

But there are a few contra-indications. The ROC has turned down. Bharti's rise during the rally has been a bit too steep. Steep rallies tend to correct sharply as well. The biggest concern is the volume - or the lack of it. Such a rally should have been supported by a rapid rise in volumes. That hasn't happened - and is a negative sign.

Bottomline? An existing holder can keep riding the rally or book partial profits. Potential investors in Bharti Airtel should keep observing the chart pattern for a decent correction and then enter.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Stock Market News, Financial News - Mar 16, 2009

Bharti to recast business in April '09

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Bharti Airtel Ltd, India's top mobile operator, will restructure its businesses next month as it looks to expand beyond voice telephony, the Economic Times reported on Monday.

The newspaper said Bharti would expand its three divisions to nine to focus on mobile commerce, Internet, enterprise business and small and medium business.  (More ...)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

iGate says Satyam bid below current market price

MUMBAI (Reuters) - U.S.-based iGate Corp's bid for fraud-hit Satyam Computer Services will be well short of the current market price, its chief executive told a television channel on Monday.

"I mean what we have picked up in terms of the financial, I do believe our bid will be quite a bit south of the 90 cents a share, which is currently the market price of Satyam," Phaneesh Murthy said on CNBC-TV18.  (More ...)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rupee off 2-week high as importers buy dollars

MUMBAI (Reuters) - The rupee retreated after climbing to its strongest in more than two weeks early on Monday, as importers bought the U.S. dollar but gains in regional currencies and local shares should support.

At 10:20 a.m., the partially convertible rupee was at 51.60/62 per dollar, after touching 51.33, its highest since Feb. 27. It had closed at 51.48/50 on Friday.  (More ...)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

US recovery to begin in 2010: Bernanke

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke suggested in a taped interview on Sunday that the US recession could last most of the year and said the biggest risk was that the political will needed to fix the fractured financial system could be lacking.

"This (economic) decline will begin to moderate and we'll begin to see a leveling off," Bernanke said when pressed during an interview on the CBS program "60 Minutes" about whether he sees the recession ending this year.  (More ...)

Sunday, March 15, 2009

About Stock Market News and Insider Trading - the Bharti case

In a blog post on Feb 1, '09, some guidelines about how to disseminate stock market news and financial news into 'good', 'great', 'bad' and 'worse' categories were provided. I had also given suggestions about how to form buy or sell strategies using such categorisation.

One of the notable stock market news items last week (on Thursday, Feb 12, '09) was the announcement that Manoj Kohli, CEO and Joint MD of Bharti Airtel had disposed off his entire stock holding in the company, comprising some 123,000 shares worth more than Rs 7 Crores.

53,000 shares were sold on Mar 6, '09 and 70,000 shares were sold on Mar 9, '09. By stock market standards, these are not huge numbers. Kohli's holdings represented less than 0.01% of Bharti Airtel's equity capital, and he isn't a founder-promoter of the company.

But the stock market took the news badly and the stock tanked by more than 6% on Thursday when the Sensex rose by more than 2%. The stock remained under pressure even on Friday and gained only 1.5% whereas the Sensex gained nearly 5%.

There were rumours of the CEO's imminent exit from Bharti, which Kohli denied. He also claimed that he held 180,000 stock options, some of which had already vested. But the near simultaneous announcement of the promotion of Sanjay Kapoor, from President - Mobile Services to a newly created post of Deputy CEO, only strengthened the rumour-mongers.

Chairman Sunil Mittal later wrote to the company's institutional investors clarifying that Kohli was very much an integral part of the Bharti top management; had taken Mittal's permission to sell his holdings; that ESOPs were meant to enrich employees; and top level reshuffles are routine affairs at Bharti.

Some analysts also pointed out that the reason for the stock's fall had less to do with Kohli's resignation and was more due to the announcement by TRAI about reduction in termination charges that telecom providers pay each other for local calls to 20 paisa (from 30 paisa earlier).

With a user base of 90 million plus, Bharti's top line may get affected by about 4% and EPS by 1% if they do not reduce their tariffs proportionately. If Bharti reduces tariffs proportionately, top line may go down by 8% and EPS by 11% (as per estimates of Macquarie Securities).

So what should investors and potential investors do? To answer that question, we must first analyse the issues in 'insider trading'.

Insider trading means buying or selling of a company's shares or debentures or bonds by individuals who may have privileged information about the company before such information is made public. In many countries, including India, it is perfectly legal for company insiders like executives and directors to buy or sell  company securities as long as it isn't done based on non-public information.

How can investors find out if any insider trading is above board or not?  A simple thumb rule is to look at the quantum of sale. (We will only discuss about insider selling. Insider buying is usually a positive, particularly in a bear market, because it demonstrates faith in the future of the company.)

National Stock Exchange records reveal that Bharti Airtel director Akhil Gupta has sold more than 90,000 shares over the past three months. Company Secretary Vijaya Sampat sold 16000 shares in Dec '08. But such information didn't affect Bharti's stock price in a major way.

Why so? Because 16000 shares is considered 'normal' profit booking. What about 90,000 shares - which is not much less than Kohli's 123,000? This is where it gets interesting.

After selling 90,000 shares, Akhil Gupta's balance holding is nearly 11 lakh shares! That means he sold less than 10% of his holdings. Whereas, after selling 123,000 shares, Kohli's remaining balance holding is zero (well, 180,000 of mostly unvested stock options).

There was also a rumour that Kohli wants to move out of Gurgaon and buy property in New Delhi. In which case, he could have sold a smaller amount that would have been enough for a down payment.

Inspite of Kohli's and Mittal's denials, there seems to be more here than meets the eye. So is this bad news or worse news? Only time will reveal that.

Bear markets have this ability of inducing reticence among promoters who are otherwise ready to blab away about their company's brilliant outlook. Bad news gets revealed in dribs and drabs.

My hunch is that there may be worse news to follow. Kohli may have done what Satyam top executives did in Dec '08. Bail out before the really bad news hits the market. I don't expect that Bharti Airtel is involved in any Satyam-like fraud. But isn't it better to be safe than sorry?

My advice to potential investors is to wait for the Bharti Airtel stock to get derated. Alternatively, if every thing turns out hunky-dory, enter when the market shows signs of turning around.

Existing investors can hold on with a stop loss at 480. If 480 doesn't hold, Bharti can go to 420.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Stock Market News, Financial News - Mar 12, 2009

Factory output drops in Jan, more falls seen

By Surojit Gupta and Rajkumar Ray

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India's factory output fell for the third time in four months in January, and with government and Reserve Bank steps to lift a sagging economy likely to take months to kick in further falls are expected.

Industrial production fell 0.5 percent in January from a year earlier, a marginally better performance than the previous month's upwardly revised contraction of 0.6 percent.

(More ...)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tata Comm sees capex up to $500 mln next FY

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Tata Communications has resources to fund ongoing capital expenditure and plans to spend about $400-$500 million during the fiscal year that begins April 1, a senior official said on Thursday.

Srinivasa Addepalli, senior vice president for corporate strategy, told reporters that did not include funds for a pending Wimax auction due later this year. (More ...)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bharti Airtel CEO says to continue as CEO, joint MD

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Bharti Airtel chief executive Manoj Kohli said on Thursday he had sold his shares in the firm for personal reasons, but still had 180,000 options and would remain as CEO and joint managing director of India's top mobile operator.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nagarjuna Construction gets orders worth 2.63 billion rupees

MUMBAI (Reuters) - Nagarjuna Construction Co Ltd said on Thursday it received three new orders worth a total 2.63 billion rupees each of which has to be completed over a period of 24 months, it said in a statement to the exchange.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Global economy to shrink 1-2 pct: World Bank

Financial Express

The global economy is on track for its worst recession since the 1930s with output likely to shrink by 1-2 per cent this year, World Bank President Robert Zoellick told the 'Daily Mail' newspaper.

Central and eastern European countries were particularly vulnerable, he said, urging rich nations to do more to fill the financing gap left by an exodus of capital from the developing world.

"My guess is that growth will probably fall about 1 to 2 per cent," he told the paper in its Thursday edition. (More ...)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

More private life insurers freeze branches

Hindustan Times

The list of private insurance firms freezing branch expansion is getting longer.
After ICICI Prudential and Bajaj Allianz, others such as Max New York Life, Kotak Life and Reliance Life are following suit, while Aviva Life Insurance has said that it will be selective in opening branches, depending on the market conditions.

Private life insurers are saying that their focus has now turned to managing rising expenses, and increasing the productivity of employees and agents, as capital runs scarce. (More ...)

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Stock Market News, Financial News - Mar 11, 2009

Citigroup cheers markets but economies still bleak

By Jonathan Stempel and Sachi Izumi

NEW YORK/TOKYO (Reuters) - Citigroup said it was profitable in the first two months of 2009 and Toshiba was reported to be set for an operating profit of $1 billion next year, two rare shards of corporate news to lift markets.

Asian stocks rose on Wednesday, following a strong rally on Wall Street, but economic news remained gloomy.  (More ...)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

'US protectionism not to impact Indian IT'

By ENS Economic Bureau

At a time when US President Barack Obama's statements on curbing tax breaks for outsourcing companies in the US rang alarm bells in the Indian IT sector, Indian IT representative body National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom) today said it does not expect the recent protectionist measures taken by the US government to impact the Indian IT-BPO industry.  (More ...)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

NHAI plans funding to road developers

By Gunjan Pradhan Sinha, Indian Express Finance

In a bid to prevent work on road projects from coming to a halt, the government is considering a proposal to allow the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) to extend working capital loans to developers. In a meeting held on March 7, the roads secretary and NHAI officials discussed the possibility of such a move with road developers. According to developers present at the meeting, the move may help them tide over the tight credit situation they face for projects undertaken by them under the National Highways Development Programme (NHDP).  (More ...)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

LandT, 8 others in race for Chennai mega container terminal

By Financial Express Bureau

Nine companies have submitted their requests for qualification for the development of India's first mega container terminal at the Chennai port. Estimated to cost Rs 3,686 crore, the terminal, with a rated annual capacity of 4 million TEUs, is likely to become operational by 2012-2013.

The last date for submitting the request was on March 9, 2009. The applicants are: LandT Transco Pvt Development Project Ltd, Chennai; Navayuga Engineering Co Ltd, Chennai; DP World Pvt Ltd, Mumbai; IL andFS Maritime Infra Co Ltd, Mumbai; Vadinar Oil Terminal Ltd, Mumbai; Mundra Port and SEZ Ltd, Ahmedabad; Lanco Infratech Ltd, Hyderabad; FGI Group of companies, Malaysia and GVK-Leighton Consortium, Mumbai.  (More ...)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nine million GSM users added in Feb, tally rises to 277 million

By Financial Express Bureau

The country added a total of 9 million GSM subscribers in February, taking the total tally to 277 million at the end of the month. This marks an increase of 3.43% in the total number of subscribers, compared to the month of January.

The country's largest telecom operator, Bharti Airtel, added the highest number of GSM subscribers during the month, at 2.5 million. With this, the total number of mobile subscribers for the company went up to about 91million. Bharti continues to have the largest market share in the GSM segment with 32.88%. Bihar once again added the largest number of subscribers for the company, with 4 lakh additions. Karnataka added the second highest number of subscribers with around 3 lakh, with Rajasthan close behind with 2.9 lakh additions in the month.  (More ...)