Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label insurance. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

What is wrong with the Mutual Funds industry in India?

A few cynics may say that everything is wrong with the Mutual Funds industry in India. They may even ask: What is right about the Mutual Funds industry? I’m not one of them. Neither do I believe that all is well.

As per recent reports, 65 fund managers have left the Mutual Funds business over the past two years – including some with ranks of CEO or CIO. Well-known stalwarts of the industry, like Ved Chaturvedi, CEO of Tata Asset Management, Nilesh Shah, Dy. MD of ICICI Prudential Asset Management and Madhu Kela, Head of Equities at Reliance Capital Asset Management, have left their jobs (though the last-named remains with the Reliance ADAG group).

One of the most famous fund managers of all time, Peter Lynch, spent the major part of his career with a single fund house (Fidelity). Anthony Bolton, another famous fund manager, also spent practically his entire career at the same fund house. There is a certain amount of stability and investor trust that builds up when the same fund manager stays at a fund house for a long period. Why are Indian fund managers leaving in droves?

Stringent regulations introduced by SEBI over the past few years have taken a lot of the ‘fun’ out of fund management. Entry loads are gone. Along with it went the fancy agency commissions. Confusing the public with a rash of New Fund Offers (NFOs) with esoteric names is a thing of the past. Not only have inflows reduced, outflows have increased as a large number of new funds promised the moon but failed to reach even the tree top.

Trying to produce results under strong regulatory scrutiny in an environment where fund inflows were drying up must be very stressful. Opportunities of earning fat performance bonuses have reduced. Lucrative opportunities in less-regulated areas of hedge funds,  private portfolio management services and investment banking may be bigger attractions for fund managers.

Anecdotal evidence from a few established distributors of mutual funds point to a shift in emphasis to selling specially packaged insurance products – particularly those with an added equity element – where day-to-day market fluctuations do not affect the investment outcome too much. Commissions are also higher. It is diverting cash that would have flown into fund houses.

But these are really secondary causes. The primary reason for the current state of affairs in the mutual funds industry is the maturity of the industry. Thanks to the barrage of information available from the pink papers, business TV channels and web sites, Indian investors can no longer be taken for a ride. They can’t be induced to part with cash with the promise of ‘dividends’ that are not dividends at all but a return of a portion of the invested funds. That means fewer opportunities for making easy money.

Is the mutual fund industry over-regulated? Some may say ‘Yes’. I think the balance has been shifted towards investors, which is good. Fund managers are realising that they should try to help investors become rich, instead of becoming rich at the expense of investors.

What do you think? Have the regulators gone overboard and started the decline of the mutual fund industry, or have they levelled the playing field in favour of investors?

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Risk Management in Investing – a guest post

In last month’s guest post, Nishit had covered the important topic of asset allocation. Without a proper asset allocation plan, investing becomes a hit-and-miss affair. You never know how much of what asset to buy, when to buy and when to book some profit. Often, the end result is missed opportunities and losses.

In this month’s guest post, Nishit covers the related topic of Risk Management. Properly assessing and understanding the risks involved in one’s investment plan and taking appropriate steps to mitigate those risks helps in formulating a proper asset allocation plan to suit one’s individual investment style and risk tolerance level.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

One of the most important topics that every person who makes any investments should be aware of is Risk Management. A good investor who is poor at Risk Management can get wiped out. Let us try to define risk and risk management.

Any activity you perform in life has a best case scenario and a worst case scenario. The worst case scenario is the risk, and the steps you take to minimise it is Risk Management. In investing, the worst case scenario is loss of capital and returns. The steps for managing risk can be:

(1) avoiding it – e.g. not indulging in day trading

(2) reducing the negative effects - learning the art of setting stop-losses and selling when the stop-loss is hit

(3) accepting the consequences – realizing that to be successful in day trading, a lot of small losses will have to be absorbed

(4) transferring it – buying insurance against trading losses

Risk in investments should be linked to the reward it offers. Risk-reward ratio is the reward which is being offered for the risk you are willing to take. Equity as an investment is risky as compared to investment in government securities, but the rewards are much higher. A 10 year government security will give you a return of 8% whereas investing in blue chip equities may give you 20% annual returns. The G-Sec investment is risk free whereas you face the risk of capital erosion in equity investments.

Risk varies as per the age and the needs of an individual. A 30 year old with a secure job that gives him a steady cash flow can take a higher amount of risk, and a riskier asset class like equity can form a higher percentage of his portfolio. A 60 year old who has just retired may have a larger capital to play with but has no steady income coming from a job. He will need to invest a much higher proportion in debt, giving him a steady income. Also, he has to guard against capital erosion as he will not be in a position to earn back the lost capital from a full-time job.

The table below illustrates the risk-reward ratios of various asset classes:

                     Reward

Risk

High

Medium

Low

High

Mid-cap Equities

Real Estate

Nil

Medium

Gold

‘A’ group Stocks in BSE

Nil

Low

Nil

Good Corporate Debt

Government Debt

Sunil Gavaskar has a favourite saying about percentage shots. He says the batsman has to consider what risk he takes of getting out when he plays a particular shot, and how many runs he scores. Sehwag plays in a very high risk-reward ratio style, whereas Sachin plays low risk shots. In IPL 3, he scored fast but scored mostly in boundaries. This is a classic example of a low risk and high reward strategy.

A good way of protecting your risks is by taking a term insurance cover which has a low insurance premium but high cover in case of your unfortunate demise. The first step of financial planning is to find out how much risk you can take. To play the game, you must remain in the game. In a game of poker, the poker player cannot afford to get wiped out. It is always better to get rich slowly rather than stake all. Twice the government yield of 10 yr paper (8% returns), which will give 16% annual returns when compounded over 10 years will turn Rs 1 lakh into 4.5 lakhs. That is the power of compound interest. Over 25 years, the same amount will turn into 40 lakhs!

Suggested Asset allocation for a 35 year old, considering the volatile state of the markets today:

Asset

% Allocation

Equity

20

Debt

40

Gold

30

Cash

10

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Nishit Vadhavkar is a Quality Manager working at an IT MNC. Deciphering economics, equity markets and piercing the jargon to make it understandable to all is his passion. "We work hard for our money, our money should work even harder for us" is his motto.

Nishit blogs at Money Manthan.)

Saturday, April 11, 2009

Sensex Chart Pattern - Week ending Apr 10, 2009

Before discussing the Sensex chart pattern for this week, I seek the indulgence of this blog's readers in a little trumpet-blowing. A leading Indian pink-sheet quoted some of the comments I made in last week's Sensex chart pattern discussion in a recent article. Interested readers may want to click on the link below:-

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/Markets/Analysis/Market-bull-run-Technicals-indicate-otherwise/articleshow/4380215.cms

I emailed my friends, assuring them that now that I'm 'famous', I promise never to forget them. While most of them sent congratulatory messages, one had a question: "You may have fame, but do you have fortune?"

Not realising that this was an outswinger pitched outside the off-stump and should be left well alone, I poked at it and asked him what he meant. Pat came a pithy comment: "There are two kinds of people in this world - those who think fortune follows fame, and those who know fame can be bought with fortune."

Ouch!! I was out - caught first ball. Guess my two minutes of 'fame' wasn't even worth the paper it was printed on! Since fortune is supposed to favour the brave, I will bravely move on to discuss the 6 months bar chart pattern of the Sensex.

Sensex_Apr1009

(Please right-click on the image above and open it in a new tab or window for a better view.)

In a truncated week with only 3 days of trading, the Sensex continued its relentless upward rally that began a month ago, and hit 10929 in intraday trade on Apr 9, '09. A whopping 36% rise from the Mar 6, '09 intraday low of 8047.

The slow stochastics is firmly in the overbought zone. MACD and ROC are both positive. The RSI is also positive and just about entering the overbought zone. The Jan '09 high was crossed in style. As per a few US market analysts, a 20% plus rise from a recent bottom is supposed to indicate a bull market.

Some how, in spite of all the positives, I'm still not convinced that this rally is the first leg of a new bull market. I may be in a minority of one, but a few technical and fundamental hurdles remain on the way.

1. The volumes are nothing worth writing home about. Barely higher in Mar '09 over Feb '09, and marginally higher in April '09 so far. A new bull market should have significantly higher volumes.

2. The 20 day EMA is above the 50 day EMA and both have started to rise. This is a bullish sign. The Sensex is above both these EMAs. Also bullish. But so far, all three have remained below the 200 day EMA, so technically we remain in a long term bear market.

3. The past one month's rally has not seen any significant correction, except the big fall on Monday, Mar 30, '09. This is an anomaly. An index can't go on rising without proper correction from time to time - unless some one is manipulating it. Who? The insurance companies, more particularly, LIC. Why? Probably under the dictats of the wily Finance Minister, to give voters a feel good factor before the impending general elections.

4. The corporate results for the financial year Apr '08 to Mar '09 will start hitting the markets from next week. They are not expected to be good. Anecdotal evidence suggests that the results for the next two quarters aren't going to be great either. Weak fundamentals can't prop up the market for long.

Now we come to an interesting fork on the road. (As the New York Yankees baseball coach Yogi Berra had famously said: "When you come to a fork on the road, take it!") This is what makes technical analysis so much fun.

The intraday high of 10929 is nearly the same as the intraday high of 10945 made on Nov 5, '08. After touching it, the Sensex dropped down more than 125 points on Apr 9, '09.

Please remember that the level of 10945 has defined the upper limit of the sideways rectangular Sensex chart pattern formed over more than 5 months. Since the Sensex is also tantalisingly below the 200 day EMA, bears may try to take control. That means the Sensex will remain within the rectangular chart pattern and the long term bear market will continue.

However, if the buying momentum continues for a few more days, and the possible resistances at 10945 and the 200 day EMA at 11200 are overcome, the Sensex may go all the way up to the 12000-12500 long term resistance zone. That may be a tough resistance to cross.

Bottomline? Keep your eyes glued to the Sensex chart over the next couple of weeks. If the bears take control and there is a sharp sell-off, one can start buying in small quantities again. If the Sensex goes up above 11500, start getting rid of some of the second and third rung stocks remaining in your portfolio.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Stock Market News, Financial News - Mar 12, 2009

Factory output drops in Jan, more falls seen

By Surojit Gupta and Rajkumar Ray

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - India's factory output fell for the third time in four months in January, and with government and Reserve Bank steps to lift a sagging economy likely to take months to kick in further falls are expected.

Industrial production fell 0.5 percent in January from a year earlier, a marginally better performance than the previous month's upwardly revised contraction of 0.6 percent.

(More ...)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tata Comm sees capex up to $500 mln next FY

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Tata Communications has resources to fund ongoing capital expenditure and plans to spend about $400-$500 million during the fiscal year that begins April 1, a senior official said on Thursday.

Srinivasa Addepalli, senior vice president for corporate strategy, told reporters that did not include funds for a pending Wimax auction due later this year. (More ...)

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bharti Airtel CEO says to continue as CEO, joint MD

NEW DELHI (Reuters) - Bharti Airtel chief executive Manoj Kohli said on Thursday he had sold his shares in the firm for personal reasons, but still had 180,000 options and would remain as CEO and joint managing director of India's top mobile operator.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nagarjuna Construction gets orders worth 2.63 billion rupees

MUMBAI (Reuters) - Nagarjuna Construction Co Ltd said on Thursday it received three new orders worth a total 2.63 billion rupees each of which has to be completed over a period of 24 months, it said in a statement to the exchange.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Global economy to shrink 1-2 pct: World Bank

Financial Express

The global economy is on track for its worst recession since the 1930s with output likely to shrink by 1-2 per cent this year, World Bank President Robert Zoellick told the 'Daily Mail' newspaper.

Central and eastern European countries were particularly vulnerable, he said, urging rich nations to do more to fill the financing gap left by an exodus of capital from the developing world.

"My guess is that growth will probably fall about 1 to 2 per cent," he told the paper in its Thursday edition. (More ...)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

More private life insurers freeze branches

Hindustan Times

The list of private insurance firms freezing branch expansion is getting longer.
After ICICI Prudential and Bajaj Allianz, others such as Max New York Life, Kotak Life and Reliance Life are following suit, while Aviva Life Insurance has said that it will be selective in opening branches, depending on the market conditions.

Private life insurers are saying that their focus has now turned to managing rising expenses, and increasing the productivity of employees and agents, as capital runs scarce. (More ...)