Showing posts with label NFO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NFO. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 28, 2010

What is wrong with the Mutual Funds industry in India?

A few cynics may say that everything is wrong with the Mutual Funds industry in India. They may even ask: What is right about the Mutual Funds industry? I’m not one of them. Neither do I believe that all is well.

As per recent reports, 65 fund managers have left the Mutual Funds business over the past two years – including some with ranks of CEO or CIO. Well-known stalwarts of the industry, like Ved Chaturvedi, CEO of Tata Asset Management, Nilesh Shah, Dy. MD of ICICI Prudential Asset Management and Madhu Kela, Head of Equities at Reliance Capital Asset Management, have left their jobs (though the last-named remains with the Reliance ADAG group).

One of the most famous fund managers of all time, Peter Lynch, spent the major part of his career with a single fund house (Fidelity). Anthony Bolton, another famous fund manager, also spent practically his entire career at the same fund house. There is a certain amount of stability and investor trust that builds up when the same fund manager stays at a fund house for a long period. Why are Indian fund managers leaving in droves?

Stringent regulations introduced by SEBI over the past few years have taken a lot of the ‘fun’ out of fund management. Entry loads are gone. Along with it went the fancy agency commissions. Confusing the public with a rash of New Fund Offers (NFOs) with esoteric names is a thing of the past. Not only have inflows reduced, outflows have increased as a large number of new funds promised the moon but failed to reach even the tree top.

Trying to produce results under strong regulatory scrutiny in an environment where fund inflows were drying up must be very stressful. Opportunities of earning fat performance bonuses have reduced. Lucrative opportunities in less-regulated areas of hedge funds,  private portfolio management services and investment banking may be bigger attractions for fund managers.

Anecdotal evidence from a few established distributors of mutual funds point to a shift in emphasis to selling specially packaged insurance products – particularly those with an added equity element – where day-to-day market fluctuations do not affect the investment outcome too much. Commissions are also higher. It is diverting cash that would have flown into fund houses.

But these are really secondary causes. The primary reason for the current state of affairs in the mutual funds industry is the maturity of the industry. Thanks to the barrage of information available from the pink papers, business TV channels and web sites, Indian investors can no longer be taken for a ride. They can’t be induced to part with cash with the promise of ‘dividends’ that are not dividends at all but a return of a portion of the invested funds. That means fewer opportunities for making easy money.

Is the mutual fund industry over-regulated? Some may say ‘Yes’. I think the balance has been shifted towards investors, which is good. Fund managers are realising that they should try to help investors become rich, instead of becoming rich at the expense of investors.

What do you think? Have the regulators gone overboard and started the decline of the mutual fund industry, or have they levelled the playing field in favour of investors?

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Why small investors should avoid IPOs, FPOs (and NFOs)

Before I delve into the details, I think it may be prudent to clarify what the TLAs (Three Letter Acronyms) mean.

IPO stands for 'initial public offering'. That means a company is issuing shares to the general public for the first time. (It may have issued shares to promoters and private investors, but such shares were not traded in a stock exchange.) IPOs are issued at 'face value' plus a premium.

FPO means a 'follow-on public offer'. Companies may have sold a small percentage of shares, say 10% or 20% of their authorised equity capital, earlier. Now they need more money for expansion and/or to retire debt. An FPO is different from a rights issue - where shares are offered only to existing shareholders. FPOs are also issued at face value plus a premium.

NFO is a 'new fund offering' from a mutual fund house. Fund houses earlier called these IPOs, but were compelled by the authorities to change the name. Why?

Because a new fund has no prior track record whatsoever, unlike most companies that have to be in business for a while and attain a particular balance sheet size before they can issue shares. NFOs are issued at face value.

The short answer to the question (and I'm not sure that the authorities will be terribly pleased with it): Because investors get taken for a ride.

Aren't IPOs and FPOs tickets to quick riches? It used to be so in the 1970s and 1980s when the pricing was pre-approved by the stock exchanges, and there was enough left on the table for investors.

The current practice of pricing shares through a book-building process(and a French auction for the recent NTPC FPO) is supposed to 'discover' the best price, but actually causes uncertainty and confusion among small investors.

The 'red-herring prospectus' that is supposed to be part of the offer document including the application form, is either not available, or printed in tiny nano fonts that require a powerful microscope to read, or too voluminous to comprehend.

The end result? Most investors fill up the application forms without going through the company details - particularly the risk factors, including pending litigation, unpaid tax demands, potential forex losses and myriad other issues that are conveniently hidden in the fine print.

Even if investors have the patience to go through all the details, it is unlikely that they will be enlightened because of forward-looking statements (read 'pure fiction') about the future growth and profitability prospects of the company.

On top of it, the price-band given for the book-building process is mostly way higher than reasonable, aimed at squeezing out the last Rupee from the pockets of gullible investors.

Compound that with the fact that most IPOs, FPOs (and NFOs) appear when the stock market is at or near a peak - and you have got a perfect recipe for making losses.

Get-rich-quick schemes - in the stock market or otherwise - never benefit the investors. It is meant for the benefit of those who sell such schemes. So stay away from IPOs, FPOs (and NFOs). Stick to the tried, tested and trusted companies and funds. You will get rich - slowly.

(A hypothetical question for investors. Some one holds a gun to your head and forces you to invest in any one of three IPOs. The first company is raising money to retire its bloated debt. The second company is raising money for some planned acquisitions. The third company is planning to buy new plant and machinery for an expansion project. Which of the three IPOs will you subscribe to, and why?)