Showing posts with label Insider trading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Insider trading. Show all posts

Friday, July 22, 2011

The curious case of Crompton Greaves

This is not a post about a court-room thriller, even though the title may sound like one of Erle Stanley Gardner’s page turners. That doesn’t mean that the process of discovery of the real cause behind the serious hammering of the stock price of Crompton Greaves may not be an exciting one.

First, the facts. A less than stellar Q1 result due to significant reduction in the consumer business (mainly electrical appliances) was a shock. That was followed by the revelation that the erstwhile CEO had dumped his entire stock holdings of 180000 shares earlier in the month.

The former CEO took pains to explain that:

(a) he doesn’t like to invest in the stock market but had received the shares as part of his compensation some 11 years back; at that time he had resolved to sell the shares immediately after retirement

(b) he retired on June 1, 2011 and sold the shares within a month of retirement after following due process of informing SEBI and the stock exchanges.

Doubts remained in the minds of investors because of three reasons:

1. Insider selling of large quantity of shares is considered a warning sign

2. Though he retired on June 1, 2011 Mr Trehan is still associated with the company though he doesn’t draw a salary. That means, he had insider’s knowledge about the poor Q1 performance of the company

3. The timing of the sale seemed a bit fortuitous. What if the stock market was in a deeper correction? Would he have sold his shares at lower prices? Alternatively, if the market was in the midst of a strong bull run, would he have waited a little longer to sell at a higher price?

Only Mr Trehan can answer those questions. Bottom line is that a lot of small investors were shaken by the severity of the stock price crash. Since such a crash didn’t occur when the ex-CEO actually sold his shares three weeks back, fingers are being pointed towards a bear cartel that used the fact of the insider sale as an excuse to hammer down the stock price. A fit case for SEBI to look into.

The Joint Managing Director of Havell’s – a competitor of Crompton in the consumer appliances space – does not believe that there is any cause of worry. Retail prices were hiked some time back due to increase in input costs. That may have led to consumers delaying their buying decisions. Another explanation is that distributors picked up more inventory in Q4 to avail of the then lower prices. That is why they lifted less inventory in Q1.

What should small investors do? On a TTM EPS of 10.61, the P/E at today’s closing price of 182.55 is 17.2. Not mouth-watering valuation by any means, but not hugely expensive either. If you are planning to enter, you may want to wait for Q2 results and then decide.

If you are holding the stock and are in profits, use the short-covering bounce up to book a part of it, and hold on to the rest. Remember the old stock market adage: When in doubt, stay out.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Is it a good idea to buy or sell shares on insider information?

Before attempting to answer the question, it may be a good idea to define what ‘insider information’ means:

‘Material information about a company that has not yet been released to the general public, but is known to the company’s board of directors, executive management, employees, consultants.’ 

‘Material information’ means information that can affect the price of a company’s stock – like M&A activities, rights/bonus/stock-split, fund raising, changes in top management, new product launches.

Usually, such material information is formally sent to the stock exchanges before announcing it in public through TV interviews or press conferences. Often, reporters of newspapers or business channels get wind of such information through their sources, and quiz management about it. And managements deny any such plans.

Some times, managements are not available to confirm or deny and the newspaper/TV channel goes ahead and releases the ‘news’. The company then denies the ‘news’ or says ‘no comments’. More often than not, the ‘material information’ is later made public by the company after a few days.

There is a good reason for this play-acting. It is illegal for any one to trade the shares of a company based on insider information. For that reason alone, it isn’t a good idea to buy or sell shares if you have insider information.

Taking or giving bribes is also illegal. But people do it anyway, because it has become the unwritten practice of doing business in India. So why not trade on insider information? What if you trade using your brother-in-law’s demat account? How will you ever get caught?

Using dubious methods to bypass the law doesn’t make the activity legal. But there are logical and better reasons for not indulging in insider trading. And the reasons are simple.

Unless you happen to be the managing director or finance director or a senior consultant of a publicly-listed company, the ‘insider information’ will come to you second-hand or third-hand. That means, those who had first-hand information would have already traded on the basis of the information. And the stock price would be reflecting their transactions.

What if the ‘insiders’ are upright and honest and did not trade on the basis of the material information? Wouldn’t that give you an advantage over the general public? Well, if the ‘insiders’ were really honest, they wouldn’t go around leaking insider information, would they?

A more important reason is the quality and financial strength of the company. Most ‘insider information’ being made selectively available to small investors are invariably about third and fourth rate companies. You will almost never get any insider information about L&T or ITC or Tata Steel. It will always be about little-known small-caps or companies that have seen better days.

A reader recently emailed me with a query about a PSU whose glory days have been left far behind. I responded that the company is trying to come out of the woods, but the technical chart looks very bearish. The reader then revealed that he had some ‘inside information’ that could lead to a sharp spike in the stock price!

Insider information and hot stock tips tend to fly around when the stock market is near a top (like now). Smart investors should use such information to sell, only if they happen to hold such stocks.

That was the long answer. The short answer is: No.

Related Post

About Stock Market News and Insider Trading - the Bharti case

Sunday, March 15, 2009

About Stock Market News and Insider Trading - the Bharti case

In a blog post on Feb 1, '09, some guidelines about how to disseminate stock market news and financial news into 'good', 'great', 'bad' and 'worse' categories were provided. I had also given suggestions about how to form buy or sell strategies using such categorisation.

One of the notable stock market news items last week (on Thursday, Feb 12, '09) was the announcement that Manoj Kohli, CEO and Joint MD of Bharti Airtel had disposed off his entire stock holding in the company, comprising some 123,000 shares worth more than Rs 7 Crores.

53,000 shares were sold on Mar 6, '09 and 70,000 shares were sold on Mar 9, '09. By stock market standards, these are not huge numbers. Kohli's holdings represented less than 0.01% of Bharti Airtel's equity capital, and he isn't a founder-promoter of the company.

But the stock market took the news badly and the stock tanked by more than 6% on Thursday when the Sensex rose by more than 2%. The stock remained under pressure even on Friday and gained only 1.5% whereas the Sensex gained nearly 5%.

There were rumours of the CEO's imminent exit from Bharti, which Kohli denied. He also claimed that he held 180,000 stock options, some of which had already vested. But the near simultaneous announcement of the promotion of Sanjay Kapoor, from President - Mobile Services to a newly created post of Deputy CEO, only strengthened the rumour-mongers.

Chairman Sunil Mittal later wrote to the company's institutional investors clarifying that Kohli was very much an integral part of the Bharti top management; had taken Mittal's permission to sell his holdings; that ESOPs were meant to enrich employees; and top level reshuffles are routine affairs at Bharti.

Some analysts also pointed out that the reason for the stock's fall had less to do with Kohli's resignation and was more due to the announcement by TRAI about reduction in termination charges that telecom providers pay each other for local calls to 20 paisa (from 30 paisa earlier).

With a user base of 90 million plus, Bharti's top line may get affected by about 4% and EPS by 1% if they do not reduce their tariffs proportionately. If Bharti reduces tariffs proportionately, top line may go down by 8% and EPS by 11% (as per estimates of Macquarie Securities).

So what should investors and potential investors do? To answer that question, we must first analyse the issues in 'insider trading'.

Insider trading means buying or selling of a company's shares or debentures or bonds by individuals who may have privileged information about the company before such information is made public. In many countries, including India, it is perfectly legal for company insiders like executives and directors to buy or sell  company securities as long as it isn't done based on non-public information.

How can investors find out if any insider trading is above board or not?  A simple thumb rule is to look at the quantum of sale. (We will only discuss about insider selling. Insider buying is usually a positive, particularly in a bear market, because it demonstrates faith in the future of the company.)

National Stock Exchange records reveal that Bharti Airtel director Akhil Gupta has sold more than 90,000 shares over the past three months. Company Secretary Vijaya Sampat sold 16000 shares in Dec '08. But such information didn't affect Bharti's stock price in a major way.

Why so? Because 16000 shares is considered 'normal' profit booking. What about 90,000 shares - which is not much less than Kohli's 123,000? This is where it gets interesting.

After selling 90,000 shares, Akhil Gupta's balance holding is nearly 11 lakh shares! That means he sold less than 10% of his holdings. Whereas, after selling 123,000 shares, Kohli's remaining balance holding is zero (well, 180,000 of mostly unvested stock options).

There was also a rumour that Kohli wants to move out of Gurgaon and buy property in New Delhi. In which case, he could have sold a smaller amount that would have been enough for a down payment.

Inspite of Kohli's and Mittal's denials, there seems to be more here than meets the eye. So is this bad news or worse news? Only time will reveal that.

Bear markets have this ability of inducing reticence among promoters who are otherwise ready to blab away about their company's brilliant outlook. Bad news gets revealed in dribs and drabs.

My hunch is that there may be worse news to follow. Kohli may have done what Satyam top executives did in Dec '08. Bail out before the really bad news hits the market. I don't expect that Bharti Airtel is involved in any Satyam-like fraud. But isn't it better to be safe than sorry?

My advice to potential investors is to wait for the Bharti Airtel stock to get derated. Alternatively, if every thing turns out hunky-dory, enter when the market shows signs of turning around.

Existing investors can hold on with a stop loss at 480. If 480 doesn't hold, Bharti can go to 420.