Showing posts with label Reliance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reliance. Show all posts

Saturday, July 18, 2020

Sensex, Nifty charts (Jul 17, 2020): bears getting bullied by Reliance bulls

FIIs were net buyers of equity on Mon. and Fri. (Jul 13 and 17), but were net sellers on the other three days. Their total net selling was worth Rs 19.59 Billion. DIIs were net buyers on Thu. Jul 16, but were net sellers on the rest four days. Their total net selling was worth Rs 15.84 Billion. 

Sensex and Nifty each gained about 1.2% for the week. Like in the previous week, the indices gained while FIIs and DIIs were both net sellers. Small investors who may have entered the market recently should learn the concept of a stop-loss - otherwise their 'paper' profits can vanish in a hurry.

India's usual trade deficit turned into a surplus in Jun '20 for the first time since Jan '02. Exports contracted 12.4% to US $21.9 Billion; imports contracted 47.6% to $21.1 Billion - leaving a surplus of about $800 Million. The sharp drop in imports indicates a slump in domestic demand.

BSE Sensex index chart pattern



For the second week in a row, the daily bar chart pattern of Sensex spent the entire trading week above its three daily EMAs in bull territory. On Tue. Jul 14, the index broke out below the 'rising wedge' pattern, only to pullback along the lower trend line of the 'wedge' during the rest of the week.

Note that the larger up trend line - drawn through the Mar '20 and May '20 lows remains intact. Only a downward breach of this trend line can bring bears back into the game. On the upside, resistance can be expected from a 640 points downward 'gap' formed on Mar 6th.

Daily technical indicators are in bullish zones. MACD is moving sideways after merging with its signal line. ROC is trying to cross above its 10 day MA. RSI has re-entered its overbought zone. Slow stochastic is about to follow suit.

All four indicators are showing negative divergences by failing to rise higher with the index, which closed at its highest level in 4 months. The index has rallied almost 11500 points (45%) from its Mar 24th low, even as the country is being ravaged by a pandemic. 

The disconnect between a bullish market that has gained mainly on the back of a single stock (RIL), and the grim reality of an economy falling into a recession is staggering. It will take a long time for the economy to recover and corporate earnings to get back on track.   


NSE Nifty index chart pattern




The weekly bar chart pattern of Nifty closed above its three weekly EMAs for the second straight week, and above the 10900 level for the first time in 4 months. Two gaps got filled in the process - the downward 'gap' of week ending Mar 13th, and the upward 'gap' formed last week.

The 20 week EMA has formed a bullish 'rounding bottom' pattern and is poised to cross above the 200 week EMA. On the upside, the 'support-resistance' zone between 11000-11250 can provide bullied bears a last opportunity to put up some resistance.

Weekly technical indicators are looking bullish. MACD continues to rise above its signal line in bearish zone. The signal line has formed a bullish 'rounding bottom' pattern. RSI is slowly rising above its 50% level. Slow stochastic is moving sideways well inside its overbought zone. 


Nifty's TTM P/E has moved up to 28.55, its highest level for the month and well inside its overbought zone. The breadth indicator NSE TRIN (not shown) is hovering in neutral zone, and may limit near-term index upside.

 
Bottomline? Ongoing rallies on Sensex and Nifty charts have overcome important resistance levels and re-entered bull territories. There are clear signs of 'distribution' from strong to weaker hands. Caution is advised.

Saturday, June 20, 2020

Sensex, Nifty charts (Jun 19, 2020): facing resistances after sharp rallies

FIIs were net buyers of equity on Thu. and Fri. (Jun 18 and 19) but were net sellers during the first three trading days. Their total net selling was worth Rs 33.2 Billion. DIIs were net sellers of equity on Fri. (Jun 19), but were net buyers during the first four days. Their total net buying was worth Rs 26.6 Billion, as per provisional figures.

After failing to protect India from Chinese incursion in Ladakh, the government has resorted to its overused jingoistic playbook. PSUs and private companies are being asked to ban or cancel orders for Chinese products and services. 

Since China's exports to India comprise only about 2% of its total exports, the jingoism is obviously targetted at the domestic audience. Many Indian companies - particularly in pharma and power sectors - are dependent on Chinese goods and services. Their competitiveness will suffer.

BSE Sensex index chart pattern



The following comments were made in last week's post on the daily bar chart pattern of Sensex: "The index may make another attempt to test resistance from the 'gap' zone. Bulls would do well to curb their enthusiasm."

The index consolidated sideways during the first three trading days, only to jump up on Thu. Jun 18 on the back of combined buying by FIIs and DIIs. Friday's foray inside the 'gap' zone was thanks mainly to Reliance touching a new high on news about fresh foreign investments.

Daily technical indicators are looking bullish. MACD is moving sideways in bullish zone after merging with its signal line. ROC is below its 10 day MA in neutral zone. RSI is moving sideways below its overbought zone. Slow stochastic is moving up towards its overbought zone. 

Note that Sensex closed at its highest level since formation of the downward 'gap' on Mar 12th. However, all four technical indicators failed to touch new highs. The negative divergences - and overhead resistance from the sliding 200 day EMA - can bring the up trend from the Mar 24th low to an end.

China continues to occupy and threaten India's border areas. Pakistan and Nepal are adding to the confusion. Covid 19 virus is spreading fast and not showing any signs of getting controlled. MSMEs are facing severe financial problems. Q1 (Jun '20) corporate results are expected to be a disaster.

RIL, HDFC twins and a handful of other large-cap stocks are boosting the Sensex and luring late-comers into the market. Time to be very circumspect. Protecting capital should be the main goal for small investors.

NSE Nifty index chart pattern



The weekly bar chart pattern of Nifty rallied to close just above its 200 week EMA, gaining about 270 points (2.7%) on a weekly closing basis. The index had closed below its 200 week EMA for the previous 14 weeks.   

Though the breach of the 200 week EMA is a bullish sign, it hasn't been a convincing breach as yet. In case of further upside, the zone between 10500-10600 may provide resistance.

Weekly technical indicators are looking bullish. MACD is rising above its signal line inside oversold zone. RSI has moved up to its neutral zone. Slow stochastic has risen to the edge of its overbought zone. Some near-term index upside is likely. 

Nifty's TTM P/E has moved up to 25.49, its highest level for the month and well above its long-term average inside overbought zone. The breadth indicator NSE TRIN (not shown) has risen sharply inside its oversold zone. Some more near-term index upside is possible.

 
Bottomline? Bear market rallies on Sensex and Nifty charts are nearing resistance levels. Short-term liquidity flows can give the impression that things are back to normal. An already weak economy has been devastated by the pandemic. The market has already gained 35% from its recent low. Further upside may be limited.

Saturday, May 23, 2020

Sensex, Nifty charts (May 22, 2020): bears remain in control

FIIs were net sellers of equity on all five trading days. Their total net selling was worth Rs 69.2 Billion. DIIs were net sellers of equity on Mon. and Fri. (May 18 and 22), but net buyers on the other three trading days. Their total net buying was worth Rs 39.38 Billion, as per provisional figures.

RBI preponed the MPC meeting to reduce repo rate by 40 bps (to 4%) in a bid to inject more liquidity into the monetary system, after the market was disappointed by PM's Rs 20 Trillion 'stimulus' announcement. Rising food inflation and looming recession can lead to stagflation. 

India's crude oil imports in Apr '20 fell 12.4% YoY to 17.28 million tonnes, thanks to low demand during the corona virus lockdown. Oil product imports dropped 6.5% to 3.35 million tonnes. However, refined products exports rose 37% YoY to 6.04 million tonnes.
 
BSE Sensex index chart pattern




The daily bar chart pattern of Sensex fell sharply on Mon. May 18 and slipped below the psychological 30000 level intra-day. It rallied for the next three days, but failed to overcome resistance from the sliding 20 day EMA. The index closed 425 points (1.4%) lower for the week.

Sensex had touched an intermediate top of 33887 on Apr 30, retracing 49.6% of its fall from the Jan 20 top (42274) to the Mar 24 low (25639). By stopping just short of the 50% Fibonacci retracement level, and forming an 'island reversal' pattern thereafter, the bear market rally got terminated. 
 
All three EMAs are falling, and the index is trading below them. The bear market has completed three months, and there are still no signs of bottom formation. Corporate performance during the first half of the financial year will not be good. The second half will depend on how well the corona virus gets contained.

Daily technical indicators are giving mixed signals. MACD has slipped below its signal line in neutral zone. RSI has hovering below its 50% level. Slow stochastic has risen sharply from its oversold zone and crossed above its 50% level. Some near-term index upside is a possibility.

RIL's huge rights issue at a substantial premium is open for subscription till June 9th. Don't expect the index to fall much till then. 

Many analysts are already calling a bottom at the Mar '20 low. Previous bear markets have never ended at the first low. Small investors should be prepared for a long haul. If you have spare cash, invest in small tranches.
 
NSE Nifty index chart pattern


The weekly bar chart pattern of Nifty gave a thumbs down to FM's explanations about the so-called Rs 20 Trillion economic stimulus, and closed below its three weekly EMAs for the 11th straight week. The index lost about 98 points (1.1%) on a weekly closing basis.

The sharp bear market rally from the Mar '20 low of 7511 to the Apr 30th intermediate top of 9889 retraced 48.3% of the fall from the Jan '20 top. Nifty fell just short of the 50% Fibonacci retracement level - terminating the rally
. It has since closed lower for three consecutive weeks, but managed to stay above the psychological 9000 level.

The 20 week EMA crossed below the 200 week EMA some time back. All three weekly EMAs are falling, which is a sign of a long-term bear market. The 'death cross' of the 50 week EMA below the 200 week EMA - which will technically confirm a long-term bear market - is awaited but appears imminent.

Weekly technical indicators are in bearish zones. MACD is moving sideways below its falling signal line inside oversold zone. RSI is sliding down in bearish zone. Slow stochastic has dropped sharply below its 50% level. Some more index downside is likely. 

Nifty's TTM P/E has remained flat at 20.97 but above its long-term average. The breadth indicator NSE TRIN (not shown) is rising inside neutral zone, hinting at near-term index
correction or
consolidation.

Bottomline? Sensex and Nifty charts are trading well below their respective 200 day and 200 week EMAs in bear markets. Positive corona virus cases continue to increase rapidly after easing of lockdown restrictions. India's economy is slipping into a recession. Protect your cash. Invest only in small quantities.

Saturday, May 16, 2020

Sensex, Nifty charts (May 15, 2020): bears regaining control

FIIs were net buyers of equity on Mon. May 11, but net sellers during the next four days. Their total net selling was worth a Rs 59.51 Billion. DIIs were net sellers of equity on Mon.. and Tue., but net buyers on the next three trading days. Their total net buying was worth Rs 10.75 Billion, as per provisional figures.

India's factory output contracted a record 16.7% in Mar '20 (thanks to the lockdown) against an expansion of 4.62% in Feb '20. For FY 2019-20, industrial production contracted 0.7% against 3.8% expansion in FY 2018-19.

Merchandise exports in Apr '20 contracted 60% to US $10.36 Billion. Imports also contracted 59% to $ 17.12 Billion. Trade deficit shrank to $6.76 Billion from $15.33 Billion a year ago.

BSE Sensex index chart pattern



The daily bar chart pattern of Sensex has formed a bearish pattern of 'lower tops, lower bottoms' after forming an 'island reversal' pattern on May 4th. The index closed below its three daily EMAs in a bear market.

By touching an intermediate top of 33887 on Apr 30, the index retraced 49.6% of its fall from the Jan 20 top (42274) to the Mar 24 low (25639) - falling just short of the 50% Fibonacci retracement level that often terminates a bear market rally.

An interesting technical pattern occurred on Wed. May 13 after PM's grand announcement of a 'stimulus package' the previous evening. The index opened with an upward 'gap' above its 20 day EMA, partly closing the downward (island reversal) gap formed on May 4, but failed to overcome the resistance from its falling 50 day EMA.

Part/full closing of a 'gap' is often followed by a continuation of the previous trend. A downward 'gap' below the 20 day EMA formed on Thu. May 14 - confirming the 'rule' and putting bulls in their place. A series of explanations by the FM about details of the stimulus package failed to stimulate the market.

Daily technical indicators are looking neutral to bearish. MACD is about to cross below its signal line in neutral zone. RSI has slipped below its 50% level. Slow stochastic is moving down towards its oversold zone after emerging from it.

What next for Sensex? Expect bulls to remain active till the massive RIL rights issue hits the market on May 20th. The main purpose of the issue is to retire high cost debt with 'no cost' loan from investors. The CMP was pumped up after poor results. The 'discounted issue price' (at a huge premium) is a trap. Here is a history lesson: Why rely on Reliance?

NSE Nifty index chart pattern



The weekly bar chart pattern of Nifty took the grand announcement of PM's Rs 20 Trillion economic stimulus in stride, and closed below its three weekly EMAs for the 10th straight week. The index lost about 115 points (1.2%) on a weekly closing basis.

The sharp bear market rally from the Mar '20 low of 7511 terminated at the Apr 30 intermediate top of 9889 - retracing 48.3% of the fall from the Jan '20 top. By falling just short of the 50% Fibonacci retracement level that often terminates bear market rallies,
Nifty's chart remained under bear domination. 

The 20 week EMA crossed below the 200 week EMA some time back. All three weekly EMAs are falling, which is a sign of a long-term bear market. The 'death cross' of the 50 week EMA below the 200 week EMA - which will technically confirm a long-term bear market - is awaited but should occur soon.

Weekly technical indicators are looking bearish. MACD is moving sideways below its falling signal line inside oversold zone. RSI is falling inside bearish zone. Slow stochastic has dropped sharply from its overbought zone. 

Nifty's TTM P/E has moved down to 20.98 but remains above its long-term average. The breadth indicator NSE TRIN (not shown) is oscillating about the edge of its overbought zone, hinting at near-term index
consolidation or correction.


Bottomline? Sensex and Nifty charts continue to trade below their respective 200 day and 200 week EMAs in bear markets. Positive corona virus cases are increasing rapidly. Any easing of lockdown restrictions can start a second wave of infections. Small investors should stay on the sidelines and protect their cash
.
 

Sunday, July 23, 2017

Sensex, Nifty charts (Jul 21, 2017): consolidating after breakouts from ascending triangle patterns

FIIs increased their buying in equity shares during the week. Their total net buying was worth Rs 18.6 Billion. DIIs turned net sellers of equity - worth Rs 12.9 Billion - as per provisional figures.

Sensex closed nearly flat - gaining just 8 points for the week. Nifty gained 29 points (0.3%) on a weekly closing basis. Both indices pulled back towards their respective 'ascending triangle' patterns from which they broke out in the previous week.

Reliance pulled a couple of rabbits out of its hat - surprisingly good Q1 (Jun '17) results and a 1:1 bonus announcement that forced bears to cover their shorts.

About 140 FPIs (foreign portfolio investors) registered with SEBI in Apr '17, indicating that India remains an attractive investment destination. The total number of FPIs with SEBI approval increased to 7947. 

BSE Sensex index chart pattern



The daily bar chart pattern of Sensex consolidated sideways after breaking out above an 'ascending triangle' pattern in the previous week.

The index touched a new high of 32132 on Mon. Jul 17, followed by a sharp pullback towards the top of the 'triangle' the next day. (The possibility of such a pullback was mentioned in last week's post.)

The rising 20 day EMA provided good support to the index, which bounced up to close above the 32000 level for the second week in a row.

Daily technical indicators have corrected overbought conditions but remain close to the edges of their respective overbought zones.

Some more consolidation is likely as the stock market tries to 'digest' Q1 (Jun '17) results. 

All three EMAs are rising, and the index is trading above them in a bull market. Dips can be used to add/enter. Look for opportunities in individual stocks that declare good results.

NSE Nifty index chart pattern



The weekly bar chart pattern of Nifty pulled back towards the top of the 'ascending triangle' pattern from which it had broken out in the previous week.

Bulls bought the dip. The index recovered to close above the 9900 level for the first time ever, but formed a 'hanging man' candlestick pattern which has bearish implications.

Weekly technical indicators are inside their respective overbought zones. ROC is showing negative divergence by touching a lower top while the index rose higher.

Nifty's TTM P/E is at 25.32 - way higher than its long-term average. The breadth indicator NSE TRIN (not shown) is inside its overbought zone.

Expect some consolidation around current levels before the index gathers strength to climb to the psychological level of 10000. The technical upward target - equal to the height of the 'triangle' from the breakout point from the 'ascending triangle' - is about 10075.

Bottomline? Sensex and Nifty charts are consolidating after breaking out above 'ascending triangle' patterns. With FIIs in buying mode, higher index levels are likely despite technically overbought conditions. Stay invested. 

Friday, January 13, 2017

To diversify, or not to diversify? That is the question.

Diversifying - in the context of business and investments - means hedging your bets, instead of putting all your eggs in one basket.

What is the main benefit of diversifying? Reduction of risk. Say, you are supplying large plastic containers to domestic paint manufacturers and have built up a reasonably good clientele.

Out of the blue, demonetisation of bank notes is announced by the government. The real estate sector goes for a toss and paint manufacturers curtail production. A big supply order of containers that you were negotiating gets cancelled.

What will you do? Shout from the rooftops about what an ill-planned disaster demonetisation has been? Or, realise the need of ridding the financial system of large amounts of untaxed cash and look for alternatives?

One alternative is to look for opportunities at other organisations in the domestic market with a need for large plastic containers - like Edible oil manufacturers. That would be a diversification.

Another alternative is to look for opportunities in the export market. A third alternative may be to make small plastic containers - used by shampoo and hair-oil makers.

Without making too many changes to your expertise and production capabilities, you now have more opportunities of growing your business and reducing risk by operating in different markets and product categories.

Peter Lynch coined the term "di'worse'ification" for companies that diversify into unrelated businesses that destroy rather than create shareholder value. A classic example?  Reliance entering the telecom services business. 

As if one brother's disastrous foray into telecom services was not enough. Now, big brother is throwing more money into the same business. The result is likely to be equally disastrous.

What about diversifying in the investment arena? Should you, or shouldn't you? Most financial experts will recommend diversification for reducing risk. That doesn't mean you buy 20 equity funds or 50 stocks.

Real diversification means investing in different asset classes after making a financial plan and an asset allocation plan depending on your goals and risk profile. 

Investing partly in equity, partly in fixed income, partly in gold, partly in a liquid fund will provide a well-rounded portfolio across different market and interest cycles.

When the stock market is booming, stocks will provide huge returns. What if the market crashes - as it often does? Fixed income instruments will continue to provide lower but steady returns, and liquid funds can be transferred to buy equity funds at lower NAVs.

Is there a downside to a planned and well-diversified portfolio? Unfortunately, yes. You will generate steady, average returns, but are unlikely to get filthy rich.

How can you get filthy rich? By becoming the next Bill Gates. Gates stuck to a single line of business, and made sure the whole world will use his company's software through shrewd negotiations with computer makers. (His di'worse'ification efforts into electronic products haven't borne fruit.)

Moral of the story? For mere mortals - like you and me - a planned and well-diversified portfolio that reduces risk and provides steady returns over many years is the route to financial freedom.

Learn more: 
What Does Investment Diversification Really Mean?

Related Post

Wednesday, October 17, 2012

Is it a good time to enter RIL post results? – a guest post

RIL recently declared what appeared to be stellar Q2 and half-yearly results, with a $1 Billion profit during the quarter (which is more than the annual turnover of many listed companies). Why did the market react indifferently to the excellent numbers? A closer inspection of the figures paints a less rosy picture.

In this month’s guest post, Nishit looks at the RIL stock from both fundamental and technical points of view to help investors take an informed decision about what to do with a stock that has been a favourite of investors for many years.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reliance (RIL – CMP Rs 812) has come out with its half yearly results. Let us find out how this bellwether stock is faring. For RIL, the main sources of profits come from 3 segments: Refining, which contributes 80% of the top line; Petrochem, which is their old bread and butter business; and oil and gas business. Retail and Broadband businesses are still in nascent stages and are yet to generate any substantial profits.

Refining business is booming and gross refining margins (GRM) are almost $9.50 per barrel. This is a decent GRM, because of high oil prices. Typically, GRMs are 8-10% of the price of oil. However, GRM was lower than the year-ago quarter, though it was higher than Q1.

Gas business has hit a roadblock with Krishna Godavari basin not generating as much gas as was earlier expected or planned. The company has also got embroiled in a controversy with the government on cost allocation for exploration.

Petrochem business, which is the old solid business, has seen margin contraction. Other income contributed almost 31% to the profits. Other income is obtained by investing surplus cash in the financial markets. This is more like a treasury operation and the income generated is like that of a financial institution.

If RIL generates 31% income from financial investing, it means it has much surplus cash but very little idea of new businesses to invest in. To be fair to RIL, they are looking at broadband and content related to broadband (e.g. Network 18 rights issue). It is also doing a share buyback, extinguishing shares by buying them from the market.

So, those buying RIL shares are buying it on the bet that its Retail, broadband and content businesses may expand into something more substantial.

RIL’s share price will depend on the gas it generates from KG Basin and also any output from its recent Shale gas purchases. A fundamental buy on RIL would be for buying its future expansions. Those who trust the management and its promises can look at buying RIL. At a valuation of a P/E of 10-12 range, the fair price comes to Rs 610 to Rs 750.

Elliot Wave analysis:

The bottom which the stock hit in October 2008 was Rs 465. After that the stock hit a peak of Rs 1149. So, if we take a corrective A-B-C to the entire up move which terminated at 1614 in Jan 2008:

  • A – 1614 – 465
  • Ba – 465 – 1149
  • Bb – 1149 – 681
  • Bc - 681 - ??? (942, 1023 or 1149 can be targets); currently made a high of only Rs 881.

Bottomline: The future outlook for RIL is hazy and only those with an appetite for risk can venture to buy it.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Nishit Vadhavkar is a Quality Manager working at an IT MNC. Deciphering economics, equity markets and piercing the jargon to make it understandable to all is his passion. "We work hard for our money, our money should work even harder for us" is his motto.

Nishit blogs at Money Manthan).

Related Posts

1. Why rely on Reliance?

http://investmentsfordummieslikeme.blogspot.in/2009/01/why-rely-on-reliance.html

2. Why did Reliance announce a share buyback?

http://investmentsfordummieslikeme.blogspot.in/2012/01/why-did-reliance-announce-share-buyback.html

Thursday, January 19, 2012

Why did Reliance announce a share buyback?

Regular readers of this blog know that I am biased against any company that has ‘Reliance’ in its name. So it should not come as a surprise that all actions by the Ambani brothers are viewed through a lens of strong suspicion by me.

If you are a dyed-in-the-wool Reliance investor, please don’t take umbrage at my tirade. Just ignore it. If you are considering an entry into this erstwhile darling of the Indian stock market, please read through and then decide.

The performance of Reliance companies have been less than stellar during the past couple of years. The stock market has punished all the group company stocks, including those of the big daddy of them all, RIL. The Ambani brothers have become wealthy beyond belief and have acquired notoriety by using various dubious means to circumvent the rules and accumulate the shares of their own companies. The hammering of Reliance group stock prices has dented their considerable personal wealth.

What better way to make a little extra cash than to announce a buyback before announcing Q3 results? RIL’s Q3 results – to be announced on Jan 20 ‘12 – is not expected to be great. That may lead to further selling of a stock that has already lost more than a third from its 2009 peak. The buyback announcement caused a price spurt – providing a nice opportunity to make a few extra bucks.

What will happen to small investors holding the stock? Not much – unless they use the current price spurt to book profits. Buybacks are a method used by companies ostensibly to ‘reward’ shareholders. How? Usually, the bought back shares are extinguished – which means they cease to exist. So, the equity capital of the company gets reduced and correspondingly, the EPS increases. The P/E ratio becomes lower, making the stock look more attractive valuation-wise.

But it all depends on how much of the equity capital gets bought back and extinguished. A similar buyback was announced six years back, but only a small percentage of the total equity capital was bought back. If it is a tiny percentage this time as well, it will have little or no effect on the EPS or P/E. RIL is likely to buy the shares from the open market – which means small investors will get no particular benefit.

A share buyback can be an indication that the management thinks that the shares are undervalued. It can also mean that the company is bereft of ideas about what to do with their money to enhance growth. More likely the latter, based on the totally unrelated ‘di’worse’ifications that the elder Ambani has undertaken of late – into sectors like retail, telecom, media.

Make no mistakes. The refinery business has been – and continues to be - a cash cow. But refinery margins are coming down and the gas business has been mired in controversies. None of the unrelated businesses have performed well so far. Technically, the chart looks weak and the stock price can fall to its 2009 low.

Related Posts

Why rely on Reliance?
1:1 Bonus announcement by Reliance Industries - is it good news for investors?

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Why good investment stocks may not be good trading stocks – and vice versa

The hundreds of stocks that are regularly traded in the BSE and NSE can be broadly separated into three groups – stocks that are good for investment; stocks that are good for trading; and, stocks that are plain junk and should not be touched.

Regular readers of this blog know that I’m neither a great fan of short-term or day trading, nor do I encourage small investors to do so. The only person that gets rich is the broker. No wonder various internet investment groups are full of brokers constantly giving short-term buy and sell calls.

However, it is a fact of life that small investors fall prey to the lure of making quick and easy money, and frequent investment groups and web sites that offer ‘free 100% sure-shot short-term calls’ as a short-cut to untold riches.

I was taken aback when I read read about a short-term sell call on Titan Industries. If the stock falls below a certain level, then it could fall by a whopping 2% more! However, if it rises above a certain level, then the uptrend will resume. A quick look at Titan’s 2 years closing chart pattern shows a more than 50% gain from its Feb ‘11 low, followed by a 3% correction that must have triggered the call.

Titan_2yr_Jun1411

Titan has gained 300% in 2 years, providing fabulous returns to long-term holders. Any sensible broker would have given a ‘buy the dip’ call instead of a short-term sell call for a paltry 2% profit.

Put it down to ignorance, or inexperience, or both. Many traders believe in the myth that all fundamentals are ‘in the price’ – so it is a waste of time to spend hours in stock analysis.

A trader, if he wants to make money consistently, has to spend hours studying technical charts to try and get into trades that will make huge profits - to cover up many small losses that are part of a trader’s life. Even a novice can take a look at Titan’s chart and conclude that a trade on the long side will be more profitable.

It is precisely because Titan is such a great stock for long-term buy-and-hold investment that it is not a good stock for short-term trading. It doesn’t provide enough wild swings to get in and out with big profits.

Is the vice versa true – that good trading stocks do not make good investment stocks? What is a good trading stock? For the answers to both questions, take a look at the 2 years closing chart pattern of Reliance.

RIL_2yr_Jun1411

Thanks to its massive market capitalisation, the Reliance stock finds a place in most large-cap and diversified equity funds as an investment-grade stock. But on 2 years, 1 year, 6 months and 3 months time frames, it has provided negative returns.

The rounding-top bearish pattern of the 200 day EMA, and the 50 day EMA trading below the 200 day EMA for the past five months are clear indications that the bears are getting the upper hand.

Experienced traders probably got seriously rich just by trading Reliance over the past couple of years. Look at the frequent and large price swings – just the kind of chart that should make traders rub their hands in glee.

The moral of the story? Whether you are a trader, or investor, or both – it improves your chances of making big money if you do your homework in selecting stocks.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Why is the stock market so excited about an unexciting budget?

These are the irreverent views of a non-economist. Take them with a pinch of salt.

It isn’t bad, so it must be good

There was a lot of uncertainty surrounding the budget this year. Rising inflation was not contained even after several interest rate hikes by the RBI. Higher interest rates were beginning to slow down Indian Inc’s growth momentum. Some tough tax measures were expected from the Finance Minister (FM). None came. The markets heaved a collective sigh of relief.

Shorts got trapped

The four months long correction in the stock markets had turned sentiments negative. All attempts at pullback rallies were getting sold into. The FIIs were selling heavily and redeploying in their home markets. Several experienced players were shorting the market. The unexpected surge in the indices on Budget Day was mainly due to short covering.

Auto sector gets an indirect boost 

A 2% excise duty cut was offered to auto makers a couple of years back as part of the economic stimulus. A roll back was discounted by the market. The FM left the excise duty unchanged. Feb ‘11 auto sales numbers have shown decent growth. Auto stocks soared on this twin good news.

Smart move from ITC

An increase in excise duty for cigarettes and other tobacco-related products was widely expected. In anticipation, ITC had increased the prices of some of its most popular brands prior to the budget. No such increase was announced by the FM. Don’t expect your pack of smokes to get cheaper. ITC’s bottom line will be a direct beneficiary.

Not so great for Mukesh Ambani

By transferring his shareholding in Reliance to a clutch of Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) companies, Mukesh Ambani ‘legally’ avoided paying income and other taxes (such as dividend distribution tax). LLPs have been brought under the purview of 18.5% MAT. Bad luck for big brother – he has to now pay taxes like a mere mortal! If only he had known earlier, he may not have built the ostentatious eyesore he calls home.

Reduced surcharge on corporate taxes

This would reduce cash outflows, and is a definite positive. Hopefully, the extra cash will get channeled into expansion activities and help to increase GDP growth. Investors may get rewarded with higher dividends.

Tax benefits for senior citizens

By reducing the qualifying age for a senior citizen from 65 to 60, several lakh tax payers will be able to avail higher tax exemptions. Some of the extra tax savings are likely to find their way into MFs and equity.

Does all this justify a 600 point rise in the Sensex today? Is the correction over? Should investors start buying again? Answers to these questions will become clearer over the next few days – now that the uncertainty about budget proposals are behind us.

Don’t let relief cloud reality. There has been little change in the global or local situations. Uprisings continue in the Middle East. Higher oil prices will further stoke the fire of inflation. Get set for another interest rate hike. FIIs were net sellers on Budget Day. The Sensex and Nifty are near strong resistance zones.

Stick to your asset allocation, and don’t get swayed by short-term index moves.