Showing posts with label UTI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UTI. Show all posts

Sunday, March 8, 2009

Two Index Funds that track the Nifty 50

In a post on Dec 8, '08, I had written briefly about the benefits of index funds and discussed about Nifty BeES, which is a ETF (Exchange Traded Fund). ETFs are traded like shares through brokers in a stock exchange, and just like for share trading, investors need to open a demat account.

In a subsequent post on Feb 22, '09, I had discussed about two balanced funds that may be more suitable for those investors who have less risk tolerance and don't have a demat account.

Index funds are ideal for the category of investors who are:

a) conservative but don't mind taking the risk associated with equity investments;

b) disinclined to track the performances of individual stocks;

c) not interested in opening a demat account

What are the specific benefits of index funds? They need very little management since they track the constituents of the respective indices. That means no dependence on the skills or whims of fund managers - leading to minimal management fees. Also, there is not much scope of out-performance or under-performance since an index fund tracks an index closely.

In the longer term, equities as an asset class tend to outperform all other assets. Regular investments in index funds provide long term wealth creation in a slow and steady fashion.

For more than 4 months, since the Sensex made a 52 week intra-day low on Oct 27, '08, there has been a rectangular sideways consolidation by the Sensex with no clearly discernible up or down trend. Such periods provide good opportunities for investments in index ETFs like Nifty BeES or index funds.

A couple of highly rated index funds that investors may want to consider are ICICI Pru Index Fund Retail and UTI Sunder, both of which track the Nifty 50 index. A brief summary of the funds are given below:-

1. ICICI Pru Index Fund Retail

Entry load - 1%, exit load - nil; Minimum lump sum investment: Rs 5000, subsequent investments: Rs 1000; Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) - available, minimum investments are Rs 1000 for monthly SIP and Rs 5000 for quarterly SIP; Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) and Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) available; Dividend option available; top holding - Nifty Futures (65%).

2. UTI Sunder

Entry load - nil, exit load - nil; Minimum lump sum investment: Rs 10000, subsequent investments: Rs 2000; SIP, SWP, STP - NOT available; Dividend option available; top holding - Reliance Industries (11%).

Both index funds have marginally out-performed the Nifty 50 over all time periods. They have lost less during shorter time periods and gained more over longer time periods. This was possible because of some amount of tweaking of the weightage in the portfolio of the Nifty 50 stocks.

My personal preference is for an index ETF like Nifty BeES over an index fund because it is easier to buy and sell ETFs any time during the day at the prevailing price (whereas a mutual fund can be bought or sold up to 3 pm on the same day's NAV and after 3 pm on the following day's NAV).

Sunday, January 4, 2009

Why rely on Reliance?

The proposed Satyam-Maytas take over deal had recently brought the issue of corporate governance to the forefront. Shareholder resistance eventually aborted the deal. Otherwise a huge amount of cash from Satyam's coffer would have been transferred to the two debt-ridden Maytas companies, headed by the sons of Satyam Chairman Ramalinga Raju.

But Raju is a minor leaguer compared to the biggest flouter of all corporate governance norms - the Ambanis.  Many may think that I am a heretic, trying to run down the group that practically invented equity consciousness among Indian investors by selling company shares to the public at large.

Don't get me wrong. I have the greatest admiration for the late Dhirubhai - for his grand vision, foresight and sheer chutzpah that has made Reliance Industries the largest Indian private sector company by market capitalisation.

What a way to do it though! I won't get into how Dhirubhai learned the ropes of the synthetic yarn and petrochemicals businesses during his sojourn in Aden, and turned a textile trading business into the huge conglomerate that the Reliance group has become.

Neither do I want to discuss the veracity of the way he bent all the rules in the book by getting licences and clearances from various ministries through bribery and coercion that benefited the Reliance group at the cost of competitors.

But I still vividly remember the twin share issues of Reliance Polyethylene and Reliance Polypropylene back in the early 1990s. Huge snaking lines stretching for several hundred metres formed in front of banks accepting the IPO applications.

The prospectus had mentioned that neither company had acquired even the land for the projects, let alone any plant and machinery. Needless to say, a few years later both companies 'disappeared', sorry, merged with the parent group. Probably after all the tax breaks that could possibly be claimed had been claimed. To read more about how Companies Act rules were bent, read page 9 of this link.

Then there was the famous UTI deal. After alloting to themselves debentures convertible to shares at around Rs 150 per share - in a highly irregular deal - the Ambanis allotted the same debentures to UTI at convertible price of Rs 400 per share.

This deal caused huge controversy and eventually led to the ouster of UTI's chairman Mr Pherwani and the collapse of the first and most popular mutual fund of India, the US 64 scheme, that caused large losses to small investors. More details are available here and in this Sucheta Dalal column.

Worst of all is the case of Reliance Petroleum. Shares were first issued in 1993 with a promise of project completion within 36 months. The project was completed in 36 months - but in 1999. Absolutely nothing was done between 1993 and 1996 - other than enjoy the shareholders' cash! Two years later, RPL was merged with RIL after promising that the two companies will remain separate. Read why here.

Fast forward to 2006. There was another Reliance Petroleum share issue! How SEBI permitted this is beyond me. Read what the Hindu Business Line wrote about it here.

Now that the RPL Part II saga is coming to an end, is everything hunky-dory again for RIL? Isn't the current price attractive for entering this counter?

Far from it. Read this article in DNA Money. The next financial year, i.e. 2009-10 will be much worse for RIL. So, if I were you, I would stay away from any investment in RIL.

Personally, I stay away from any stock which has the word 'Reliance' in it. The Ambanis are just not trustworthy enough - not for my money any way.