Showing posts with label multibagger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label multibagger. Show all posts

Friday, April 1, 2016

Risk vs. Return - a T20 Cricket analogy

There was a time, when cricket matches were played over 6 days - 3 days of cricket followed by a rest day, and then 2 more days. They were called test matches. 

Players behaved like gentlemen. The umpire's decision was final. There were no TV reviews or 'snicko-meters'. If a fielder didn't take a catch cleanly, or stepped over the boundary rope doing so, he signalled it promptly to the umpire.

There was fierce competition, but no sledging. Batsmen appreciated a good ball by an opposing bowler. Fielder's appreciated a good stroke by an opposing batsman. A maiden over was applauded by spectators.

Test matches are still played - over 5 days. But they often finish in 3 or 4 days. Why? Because batsmen and bowlers adopt tactics they have learned by playing the shorter versions of the game - like slower balls, scoop shots and reverse sweeps.

Initially, there were 60 over games. India, under the captaincy of Kapil Dev, won the World Cup in 1983 by scoring 183 runs. They were all out in the 55th over. West Indies managed 140 in 52 overs. Those scores are now considered inadequate in T20 cricket! 

In the inaugural World Cup in 1975, a gentleman by the name of Sunil Manohar Gavaskar remained not out for 36 runs after carrying his bat for the entire 60 overs against England. That was probably his way of protest against the shorter version of the game.

Many (including yours truly) don't like T20 cricket. The art and finesse of out-thinking a bowler or batsman by working on their weaknesses for 10 or 15 overs has almost been forgotten. Now the emphasis is on heavy bats with which it is easier to hit sixes.

Batsmen have forgotten the meaning of 'footwork'. Bowlers can no longer scare a batsman into submission with bouncers because batsmen have additional protection from helmets, arm guards, chest pads, thigh pads. In any case, bowlers are restricted to 1 or 2 bouncers per over.

(People talk about Sachin Tendulkar as an all-time great because of all the hundreds he scored. But has anyone kept a score of how many times Sachin was hit on his helmet? Gavaskar never wore a helmet and hit hundreds against fearsome West Indian fast bowlers like Holding, Roberts, Marshall.)

Virat Kohli is one of the few modern batsmen who has shown that footwork and proper cricketing shots have a place in T20 cricket as well. He has cut down on risk by hitting more shots along the ground - only resorting to hitting a 6 when the situation demanded it, like in the recent T20 World Cup group match against Australia.

By contrast, Bangladesh threw away their group match against India by taking on undue risk by trying to hit over-boundaries when they could have easily won the match by taking a couple of singles.

And there lies a lesson for young investors, who feel that high risk is associated with high returns. Investing is not a T20 game of 3 hours. It is more akin to 6 day test matches of olden days.

To build wealth from the stock market, you have to plan a strategy well in advance and execute it over a long period of time. Buying a penny stock and hoping for multibagger returns is like dancing down the track to hit a 6 in a T20 game. More often than not, you will either get stumped, or get caught in the deep.

As Geoffrey Boycott once said to a schoolboy cricketer: "Don't get out. The runs will come." 

Friday, June 5, 2015

The Risks & Rewards of Penny Stocks

Message boards in many investment groups and web sites are full of 'buy' recommendations for unknown small-cap stocks. Why do small investors get attracted - like moths to a flame - by such recommendations?

Two reasons: desire for instant gratification and greed. No one is willing to put in the time and effort in studying the fundamentals of a company. Much easier to follow some one's tips - and more fun if it is a penny stock, because more is the possibility of a multi-bagger.

End result? Getting stuck with unsaleable stocks, losing money, and losing faith in the stock market. Moral of the story? Small investors should read and learn about the stock market before spending a single Rupee. When they are ready, they should get their feet wet by investing through mutual funds.

Should small stocks be avoided entirely? Yes, if you are a novice. No, if you have paid your dues and appreciate and understand the risks involved.

In a recent article at investopedia.com, the risks and rewards of buying penny stocks have been explained. You can read the article here.

Related posts

The futile quest for the mythical 'multibagger'

'Fatal Attraction', or why small investors prefer small-cap stocks

Saturday, May 9, 2015

Technical updates – L&T and JK Lakshmi Cement

Stocks from the infrastructure sector were in doldrums due to the economic slowdown, and had fallen to two year lows during the second quarter of 2013-14. The ground-swell from Modi’s campaign brought them out of bear markets.

Once the Modi government came to power, many infrastructure stocks rose spectacularly, and provided multibagger gains. However, during the past one year, there has not been much progress in disentangling of stuck projects or initiation of new ones. High interest rate also played spoilsport.

Earnings of infrastructure companies haven’t kept pace with their stock prices. While stock prices haven’t crashed, large-cap and mid-cap stocks are down from their two year highs, and have entered sideways consolidations. The stocks of L&T and JK Lakshmi Cement are good examples.

L&T

LnT_May0815

After a 1:2 bonus issue in Jul ‘13 (marked by bell on chart), the stock of L&T dropped to a low of 695 on Sep 3 ‘13. From there, it rose to touch a high of 1752 on Jun 9 ‘14 – a huge 150% gain in 9 months.

The stock has since been in a sideways consolidation within a ‘rectangle’ pattern. The stock broke out above the ‘rectangle’ on good volume support and touched a two year high of 1843 on Mar 2 ‘15. But it failed to sustain above the ‘rectangle’. It subsequently formed a ‘head-and-shoulders’ reversal pattern with an upward-sloping neckline within the ‘rectangle’, and corrected below its 200 day EMA.

Daily technical indicators are looking bearish and oversold. A pullback towards the upward-sloping neckline is a possibility. A ‘rectangle’ pattern is usually a continuation pattern – which means the eventual break out should be upwards. But there has already been a failed break out and a reversal pattern formation. It may be better to wait for upcoming annual results to decide whether to buy, sell or hold.

JK Lakshmi Cement

JKLakshmi Cement_May0815

The stock of JK Lakshmi Cement rose from a two years low of 55, touched on Aug 5 ‘13, to a two years high of 407, touched on Jan 19 ‘15 – a whopping 640% gain in less than 18 months. The stock has been consolidating sideways within a ‘rectangle’ pattern with a downward bias since touching its Jan ‘15 high.

The stock is currently receiving twin support from the lower edge of the ‘rectangle’ (at 340) and its 200 day EMA. Despite the correction, valuation looks quite stretched.

Daily technical indicators are in bearish zones, but showing some upward momentum. A technical bounce is a possibility. Sequential QoQ results have shown decline in top and bottom lines for the past three quarters. Check annual results before initiating any action.

Sunday, March 22, 2015

Sunday musings: dichotomy in an investor’s psyche?

According to Hindu mythology, Lord Krishna was an ‘avataar’ of Lord Vishnu – born in human form to rid the world of evil forces. (“Paritranaya sadhunam vinasaya ca duskrtam, dharma samsthapanarthaya sambhavami yuge yuge” – Bhagavad Gita, Ch. 4:8)

How Krishna was born to Devaki and Vasudeva inside a prison, how he was smuggled out to live his early life in the cowherd family of Yasoda and Nanda, how he grew up to slay his evil maternal uncle, King Kansa (who had imprisoned his parents) are known to  many.

In his young days, Krishna was a playful and mischievous cowherd. He liked to play his flute and dance and play pranks on the ‘gopis’ (milk-maids), who loved him and revered him. In between, he did kill a demon or two – but those may be stories to establish Krishna’s divinity.

In later life, Krishna indirectly led the Pandavas to victory over their cousins, the Kauravas in the battle at Kurukshetra. But is it the same adorable prankster Krishna who later became the calculating and shrewd politician depicted in the epic Mahabharata?

Several experts and commentators on the Upanishads and Puranas have raised doubts. There is no mention of Krishna’s early life in the Mahabharata. So, it is possible that the stories of the cowherd Krishna was amalgamated with those of the shrewd politician Krishna (or vice versa) at a later date.

Considering the ‘colourful’ past of several of our politicians, it is quite likely that the cowherd Nandalal (son of Nanda) and the politician Parthasarathi (charioteer of Arjuna) are one and the same. (‘Colourful’ may be an over-statement, since the dominant colour is usually black.)

Most small investors start their investing life as mischievous cowherds – flirting with ‘gopis’ (i.e. small-cap stocks) and trying to steal ‘makhan’ (i.e. catch multibaggers) without a care in the world. Sooner than later, they get caught (i.e. lose their money).

The few who manage to become long-term wealth builders, learn to be shrewd and calculating. They ‘develop a system of investing that suits their psyche’ and ‘follow that system in a disciplined manner’.

There is no real dichotomy in being carefree and fun-loving (in real life) and being shrewd and systematic (in investments). But it requires patience and discipline – and the understanding that investing is not a game.

Friday, July 4, 2014

‘Fatal Attraction’, or why small investors prefer small-cap stocks

A few years back, I had written a post: Why small investors should avoid small cap stocks. The effect on small investors was the same as water on a duck’s back – it didn’t last long. With the stock market indices hitting new highs today, more and more small investors are getting ready to enter the market.

What stocks will they be after? L&T? ITC? Reliance? Glaxo? Tata Motors? M&M? TCS? Not a chance! Those stocks are too expensive. Too old-fashioned. They belong to the portfolios of grey-haired grandfathers, and are unlikely to give multibagger returns in 3 to 6 months. The name of the game is quick money.

And so, another generation of young investors are going to suffer from the ‘fatal attraction’ to small cap stocks in the hope of hitting a ‘six’ – just like it happens in every bull cycle. How do I know? Been there and done that. And lived to tell the tale, albeit with a big hole in my pocket.

If you buy a small-cap stock and it immediately spikes up and doubles your investment within a matter of days, you won’t know what you did wrong! Picking that stock at that time was pure luck – unless you happen to be knowledgeable about fundamental and technical analysis.

A bull market is like a high tide that lifts all boats. Stocks with ridiculously poor fundamentals often rise the highest in a short span of time due to their small trading volumes – sucking in investors and separating them from their hard-earned cash. Such stocks plummet just as fast, giving no chance to investors to exit.

Typically, small-cap companies belong to owners who wish to retain majority control and service a small niche product or service segment. The good news is that small niche segments are avoided by large players because of lower profit potential or lack of technology or expertise in the field.

That allows a niche segment leader to dominate the segment and make good profits without any threat from the big guys. That is why some small-cap companies often deservedly get high valuations and provide good returns to shareholders. But such ‘good’ companies are few and far between.

Many small-cap companies are out there to fleece the public. They make money from the IPO. Then they make money from the plant and equipment they install. Then they take bank loans for expansion and siphon off the funds to a chain of unrelated privately-held subsidiaries. Then they indulge in circular trading to jack up their stock price to trap unsuspecting buyers.

Then change their name, and repeat the whole fraudulent process. If they get caught, they bribe their way out and disappear to South America or Dubai. Their low equity capital facilitates price manipulation – which is not possible in a large-cap stock.

There is a market myth: small-cap stocks will become large-cap some day. Aren’t the large-cap stocks of today the small-caps of yesterday? Yes. That does not mean every small-cap you buy will eventually make the transition. Most will not. Some will remain small-cap for 50 years. Others will disappear from the face of the earth (with your money!).

Small investors have three choices about investing in small-cap stocks:

1) avoid small-caps completely and stick to large-caps or mutual funds (less adrenaline rush but good returns);

2) spend time and effort to learn how to pick stocks through detailed analysis (it is not rocket science – neither is it as simple as opening a demat account and listening to experts on business channels about what to buy);

3) subscribe to my Monthly Investment Newsletter that provides detailed fundamental and technical analysis of an under-the-radar small-cap stock every month. A limited number of paid subscriptions will be available till July 21, 2014.

Sunday, March 16, 2014

Sunday musings: there is nothing holy about the colour of money

At a convocation of a local management institute, a businessman had the following words of advice to the graduating students: There are two kinds of women in this world – those who like to be pursued and those who prefer to be left alone. Ma Durga’s two daughters exemplify the difference.

Ma Saraswati (Goddess of Learning) likes to bestow her blessings on any one who pursues her persistently and sincerely. Ma Lakshmi (Goddess of Prosperity) is more choosy – preferring to shower her blessings on those few who are prepared to wait for her arrival at her chosen time. If she feels unwelcome, she doesn’t stay for long.

Not too long ago, India was a poor country but it valued education. The well-educated had a pride of place in society even if they were not wealthy. When Swami Vivekananda visited the USA 120 years ago, he was a penniless monk who depended on the charity of others. But he won the hearts and minds of everyone (save the orthodox Christians) because of his demeanor, knowledge and wisdom.

‘Progress’ has changed our outlook towards life. Education is no longer a lifelong pursuit, but a means to become rich. Many engineers join management institutes and specialise in Finance or Marketing or HR in a race to get hired by an investment bank or a consulting company at seven figure salaries. The engineering degree goes to waste.

Very few doctors are able to diagnose and cure people. They prescribe several tests at a diagnostic centre and prefer to go on foreign junkets bankrolled by drug companies instead of spending their time on learning about latest innovations in their fields of speciality. Unnecessary operations are carried out where a simple regimen of medicines and exercises would suffice.

Semi-educated ruffians join politics and become MLAs and MPs with a single motive – to get immensely wealthy in a short period. Instead of serving the people, they expect people to serve them. They realise too late that amassing money of the wrong colour can turn them into state guests for a long time.

Legendary investors have imparted their experiences and wisdom through thick tomes that clearly chalk out how to go about building wealth through well-planned investments over the long-term. A short-list of such books have been put up on this blog since inception.

How many have read those books? Of the few who have done so, how many have read them more than once? But there has been less hesitation in wasting money on F&O contracts or in chasing after mythical multibaggers in an effort to get rich quickly. 

Most small investors fall into the trap of forsaking Ma Saraswati in the mindless pursuit of Ma Lakshmi - with tragic consequences. Blessings are received from neither.

Related Post

The futile quest for the mythical 'multibagger'

Friday, May 17, 2013

What is fuelling the stock market rally?

Many analysts – specially those who have been caught on the wrong foot – are finding it difficult to explain the reasons behind the current rally in the stock markets. The easiest way out is to say: “It is a liquidity driven rally.” But aren’t all rallies liquidity driven? If buyers didn’t overwhelm sellers, the market would remain stagnant.

If the Sensex falls 1000 points in a week, investors want to know what caused the fall, and whether a bear market has started. Analysts are more than happy to satisfy the curiosity with their considered opinions based on fundamental analysis, or technical studies, or astrological alignments.

If the Sensex rises 1000 points in a week, investors want to know if it is a good time to buy. Analysts jump in to list out their favourite small/mid/large cap ideas that are just the kind of stocks that would provide multibagger returns.

Whatever be the trend of the stock market, investors always have this insatiable need to know why the market is doing what it is doing. As if analysts really know! At best, they may have a reasonably good idea.

French author, critic and journalist Jean-Baptiste Alphonse Karr had made the statement: "Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose" – which is usually translated as “the more things change, the more they stay the same”. He may just as well have said it about the unnecessary curiosity of stock market investors about the direction of a market index.

In a recent post, a bullish technical chart pattern that has been forming on the Sensex for more than 2 years was explained to justify why the Sensex should touch 25,000. Some readers scoffed at the conclusion. A few wanted to know how soon might the target be achieved.

What was the purpose of writing the post? To partly dispel the overwhelming mood of negativity among many small investors. The high inflation and slow down in economic growth seemed to dampen any enthusiasm to invest money into a ‘risky asset’ like stocks. Gold or bank fixed deposits appeared safer bets.

Inflation-beating returns require judicious and timely investment in stocks – regardless of the level or direction of a stock index. Then, discipline and patience are required to hold on to the stocks for the long-term, without worrying too much about why the stock market is rising or falling.

That was the long answer. The short answer is: “Who cares?”

Thursday, November 24, 2011

Do investors have the ‘if-its-free-I’ll-take-two’ syndrome?

Before I can answer the question, I need to tell the story about the syndrome.

A young boy was being taught by his father about prudence in handling money. Here are the three important guidelines provided by the father:

  • Live within your means and try to save money from whatever little you may have
  • Always ask the price of anything you wish to buy, and then decide if you can afford to buy it
  • Don’t blindly accept a quoted price; try to bargain and buy at a lower price

Well-versed in the guidelines, the young boy went to the local ‘paanwala’ to buy some candy. On being told that the candy cost a Rupee, he promptly started to bargain. Despite repeated pleas by the ‘paanwala’ that there was no discount on a candy costing a Rupee, the boy would not relent. A small crowd had gathered on hearing the commotion, and potential customers were walking away. In desperation, the ‘paanwala’ handed over a candy to the boy, saying: “Take this. It’s free. Now please leave.” The boy was delighted, but refused to budge. “It’s free? Then I’ll take two!”

That boy must have grown up to be a stock investor. He also must have told all his friends – who also became stock investors. How do I know this? Because of the proliferation of web sites offering “sure-shot free stock tips” and “99.9% success guaranteed Nifty tips”.

There was a time when I used to go out of my way to provide free advice to young investors about what stocks to pick and how to build a portfolio. But I no longer give free advice – except in my blog posts. Why? Because I found out that most investors were not following my advice at all. In fact, they were doing just the opposite. They would not buy the stocks I’d recommend, and would go right ahead and buy the stocks I suggested that they avoid!

Then a wise reader related the story of a doctor in a small town who decided to treat patients for free after his retirement. Hardly any one showed up at his chamber. Then he decided to charge a reasonable fee. Soon, he had several patients visiting his chamber every day. The moral of the story is: No one respects free advice.

The other day, I received an email: “Can you please suggest one multibagger stock?” Usually, I ignore such emails, or answer back: “I don’t provide free stock advice.” But I was in a genial mood that day, and wrote back: “Buy Tata Steel.” The response floored me completely. Let alone thank me, this smart fellow came back with: “Any penny-stock multibagger?” This is what I meant by ‘if-it-is-free-I’ll-take-two’ syndrome!

A more dangerous affliction is the ‘if-it-is-free-I’ll-take-as many-as-possible’ syndrome. I got this email from such an investor: “I would like to buy some fundamentally strong stocks in this bear market. Please send me a list of such stocks.” I answered: “I don’t give individual stock advice for free. But you can take a look at some of the beaten down stocks in the Sensex and Nifty indices.”  Back came a response: “OK, I promise to send your fee, but send me the list of stocks now.” I didn’t bother to reply, only to receive this reminder: “I still haven’t received the list of stocks.” Later, I found out that this freeloader was regularly providing free stock tips in one of the investor forums!

The answer to the original question is: Many investors do. I think it is part of the human psyche that we get swayed by products that are offered ‘free’. That is why retailers periodically offer “Buy-1-get-1-free” deals to get rid of unsold or unfashionable or oversized/undersized stock. Shops tend to be overcrowded during such offers.

When it comes to stock advice, ‘free’ usually means ‘not good’. Investors need to appreciate that. If some one really knew which stocks will become multibaggers in future, he would not tell a soul and buy as many of those stocks he could afford before the stock market got wind of it. 

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Planning for a hassle-free Retirement (a guest post)

Do you remember what you did with your first pay/payment cheque? (Haven’t received your first cheque yet? What are you doing on this page!) Did you blow it up having a good time with friends and family? Why not? You don’t remain young forever. There is a long and bright future ahead of you – and plenty of time to save and invest. Right?

Nishit doesn’t think so. He started planning for his retirement as soon as he received his first pay cheque. He wanted to use the leverage of compounding over his entire working life. In this month’s guest post, he explains why.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Everyone invests money with the aim of having a comfortable nest egg at retirement. Most of us have not worked out how much money we need at retirement, and at what rate of return we will be comfortable. Most of us chase multibagger returns in the equity markets, burning our fingers in the process.

The magic of compounding is such that 1 lakh invested in the markets today turns into 19 lakhs after 20 years at a rate of 16% return every year. To make 16% every year your asset portfolio need not take undue risks. A Government securities fund over the past 10 years has given a compounded return of 9% on an annualized basis, and a good mutual fund like the HDFC Top 200 has given annualized return of 34% over the past 10 years.

Inflation is a monster which is like a silent killer. Now assuming an inflation rate of 8%, after 20 years, expenses of 1 lakh become 4.66 lakhs. Your assets of 1 lakh have transformed into 19 lakhs whereas the expenses have just gone up to 4.66 lakhs. You have a nice cushion of 14 lakhs.

Gold as an asset class has also yielded an annualized compounded return of 17% over the past 10 years. The trio of equity, gilt funds and gold should form the cornerstone of any investment portfolio. What I am trying to point out here is that investments need not be complex; any common person can invest making use of investment vehicles like Mutual Funds.

The above returns are through investments using the SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) method. One can invest a fixed amount every month, say Rs 5000 each, in a gold ETF, equity fund and a Debt fund. The idea of doing this is that you do not try and catch the bottom or top of any market. One need not invest in too many funds at one go.

India’s economy is growing and will continue to do so for the next 10 years at least. Anyone who is planning to retire with a comfortable income must start doing a SIP at the earliest. By doing this, one can ensure that one is financially independent after retirement. Add to this a Medical Insurance policy that will cover major health care expenses post retirement. The earlier one buys a Medical Insurance policy the fewer are the tests one has to undergo and easier it is to get one. Everyone should have a personal medical health insurance policy, as company policies expire when one leaves the company.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Nishit Vadhavkar is a Quality Manager working at an IT MNC. Deciphering economics, equity markets and piercing the jargon to make it understandable to all is his passion. "We work hard for our money, our money should work even harder for us" is his motto.

Nishit blogs at Money Manthan.)

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Why small investors should avoid small cap stocks

There are several reasons why small cap stocks should not be considered for investment by any investor - new or old, small or large. Before I start to argue my case, let me define what is a small cap stock.

The market capitalisation (or market 'cap') of a stock is the product of a stock's current market price and the total number of equity shares outstanding. In other words, a stock having total outstanding equity shares of 10 Million (1 Crore) and a price of Rs 100 has a market cap of Rs 1 Billion (100 Crore).

The question is: What market cap makes a company a small cap, or a mid cap or a large cap? The short answer is: It depends on whom you ask. There are no precise definitions. The industry norm for a small cap company seems to be a market cap of upto Rs 2500 Crore!

A mid cap company has market cap ranging from Rs 1000 Crore to Rs 13000 Crore. Large caps are those forming part of the Sensex 30 and Nifty 50 stocks. As you can see, the whole thing is pretty confusing.

Small investors get attracted to small caps because of two main reasons - 'affordability' and greed. Most small companies are also small cap companies that trade typically at few tens of Rupees. This price is attractive to small investors with small capital. (Many don't realise that a Rs 30 stock may have a Re 1 face value and may be trading at a P/E of 30.)

Many of today's large caps were small caps 10 or 12 years back. The general assumption is that all small caps have the potential to become large caps and give multibagger returns. But only a small minority out of the thousands traded in the stock market actually make the transition. Most will remain small caps, or disappear into the sunset.

Why are small cap stocks so risky that they are best avoided by small investors?

  • lack of transparency of management
  • lack of adequate research by fund houses and brokers
  • lack of financial muscle
  • low liquidity
  • high volatility

Management is too busy trying to survive (or siphon off money) to look after investor relations and proper communication of plans. Fund houses shun such stocks, so analysts don't cover them or visit their factories to ask tough questions.

One or two bad quarters can wipe out a small company, who may not have access to big money. Low volume of trading leads to difficulty in getting in or out, and wild price swings if small quantities are traded.

Only those investors with adequate experience and knowledge of fundamental and technical analysis should attempt investing in small cap stocks. That too, with the awareness that the entire investment can go down the drain. Preferably, the investment in small cap stocks should be limited to 10% of total portfolio value, to mitigate the risks involved.

The vast majority of investors should look for more expensive but less risky large cap stocks, or stick to index funds or index ETFs. Always remember Warren Buffet's investment rule: Don't lose money.

Related Post

The futile quest for the mythical 'multibagger'

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

The futile quest for the mythical 'multibagger'

Legend has it that the Philosopher's Stone had the unique ability of turning iron and other base metals into gold - the ultimate 'multibagger'. For a long time, the quest for the stone became an obsession in western alchemy.

"Many many years ago, a man decided that he would give up worldly comforts and riches, and dedicate his life to finding the Philosopher's Stone. He set out on his quest with an iron chain in his hand. Whenever and wherever he found a stone, he would stoop to pick it up and touch it against the chain to see if it turned to gold or not.

Many days and months passed, but he never wavered in his quest. He became thin and his hair turned into knots and his beard became long and unkempt. But the desire in his heart didn't wane.

He travelled through many countries and continents, from the mountains to the oceans. Never did he stop to appreciate the beauty of nature all around him. With a piercing gaze he picked out every single stone and kept touching it to the iron chain to check if it had turned to gold.

After a few years, it started to dawn on him that his quest may never reach fruition. Out of sheer habit, he carried on and picked up stones and touched the chain with them. He started getting weary and his heart became heavy, and he no longer bothered to check if the chain had turned into gold.

Once he was passing through a village square, where some small children were playing. They saw this wild-eyed man in tattered clothes, knotted hair and tangled beard coming towards them. One of them exclaimed: 'Look, look! That crazy man is carrying a shining gold chain.'

The man stopped dead on his tracks. In sheer disbelief, he looked at the chain in his hand. It was a solid gold chain. During his long quest, he had found the Philosopher's Stone after all. But he had thrown it away, like all the others, after touching it to his chain without checking.

In sheer despair, he sat down and pondered his fate for a while. After some time, he sighed, got up and resumed his quest."

The moral of the story? It is the rare and fortunate investor who can find more than one multibagger stock in his entire investment career. Such good fortune happens more through chance than by design.

Why is that? Because most of us do not plan to hold a stock long enough in our portfolio for it to generate stupendous returns. Does it mean that holding any stock for a long time will automatically generate multibaggers? The answer is obviously 'No'.

That is why, selecting fundamentally strong stocks is so important. Once the preliminary hard work of proper stock selection is done, one should keep holding such stocks, and at most, book partial profits from time to time.

The trick is to keep buying back these shares during a down turn, at lower prices. Doing this with just a couple of stocks, like Tata Steel or L&T, can provide huge returns.

Can momentum, or 'fashionable', stocks provide multibagger returns? The answer is 'Yes'. Pantaloon and DLF have been multibaggers. But how many small investors were able to reap the multibagger returns?

My guess would be, very few. Most would have exited after the stock doubled or tripled. And the unfortunate few, who actually got the multibagger returns, probably held on too long and are facing losses now because of the steep bear market fall.

(Notes: 1. The above story is a prose version of a famous Tagore long poem, titled 'Parash Pathor'. Satyajit Ray made a highly entertaining movie with the same title, about a person who actually finds the Philosopher's Stone and what happens to him because of it.

2. I'd be very interested to hear from readers about any multibaggers they hit or missed.)

Related posts

How to pick Stocks for Investment - Part III
How to build wealth using a buy and hold strategy